Mattheos N, Wismeijer D, Shapira L
Faculty of Dentistry, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2014 Mar;18 Suppl 1:24-32. doi: 10.1111/eje.12074.
In recent years, opportunities for postgraduate university education in implant dentistry have increased significantly, with an increase in both the number but also the complexity of available postgraduate programmes. However, there appears to be a lack of standards directing the learning outcomes of such programmes.
A scientific literature search was conducted for publications reporting on university programmes within implant dentistry, including description of programmes and evaluation of learning outcomes. A separate Internet search was conducted to collect information on existing university programmes as presented on university websites.
Implant dentistry has reached a critical mass of an independent, multidisciplinary and vibrant domain of science, which combines knowledge and discovery from many clinical and basic sciences. Many university programmes conclude with a master's or equivalent degree, but there appears to be a great diversity with regard to duration and learning objectives, as well as targeted skills and competences. The importance of implant dentistry has also increased within established specialist training programmes. There was little indication, however, that the comprehensive aspects of implant dentistry are present in all specialist training programmes where implants are being covered.
Although universities should maintain the options of designing academic programmes as they best see fit, it is imperative for them to introduce some form of transparent and comparable criteria, which will allow the profession and the public to relate the degree and academic credentials to the actual skills and competences of the degree holder. With regard to established specialist training programmes, the interdisciplinary and comprehensive nature of implant dentistry needs to be emphasised, covering both surgical and restorative aspects. Finally, implant dentistry is not, at present, a dental specialty. The profession has not reached a consensus as to whether the introduction of a new recognised specialist field is either necessary or desired.
近年来,种植牙科研究生大学教育的机会显著增加,研究生课程的数量和复杂性都有所提高。然而,似乎缺乏指导此类课程学习成果的标准。
对报道种植牙科大学课程的出版物进行科学文献检索,包括课程描述和学习成果评估。另外进行了互联网搜索,以收集大学网站上展示的现有大学课程信息。
种植牙科已发展成为一个独立、多学科且充满活力的关键科学领域,它融合了许多临床和基础科学的知识与发现。许多大学课程以硕士学位或同等学位结束,但在课程时长、学习目标以及目标技能和能力方面似乎存在很大差异。种植牙科在既定的专科培训项目中的重要性也有所增加。然而,几乎没有迹象表明,在所有涵盖种植牙的专科培训项目中都体现了种植牙科的全面内容。
尽管大学应保持根据自身最佳判断设计学术课程的选择权,但对它们来说,引入某种形式的透明且可比的标准势在必行,这将使行业和公众能够将学位和学术证书与学位持有者的实际技能和能力联系起来。关于既定的专科培训项目,需要强调种植牙科的跨学科和全面性,涵盖外科和修复方面。最后,目前种植牙科并非一个牙科专科。对于是否有必要或是否希望引入一个新的公认专科领域,该行业尚未达成共识。