Square-Storer P, Darley F L, Sommers R K
Graduate Department of Speech Pathology, University of Toronto/Mount Sinai Hospital, ON, Canada.
Brain Lang. 1988 Jan;33(1):65-85. doi: 10.1016/0093-934x(88)90055-7.
Nonspeech and speech auditory processing skills as well as internal speech processing skills were assessed among four patients with acquired "pure" apraxia of speech, 10 with acquired aphasia, 10 with aphasia plus apraxia of speech, and 11 neurologically normal adults. Fourteen tasks were administered and performances on 68 variables were examined using both nonparametric and parametric analyses controlling for the effects of advancing age and associated hearing loss. In all cases, the "pure" apractic patients performed as normal subjects. Few differences were noted among the performances of the aphasic and aphasic-apractic subjects. Results led to three major conclusions: (1) apraxia of speech is a disorder distinct from aphasia; (2) aphasic individuals, despite locus of lesion, demonstrate disabilities for processing nonspeech and speech materials presented auditorily and for analytically evaluating speech evoked internally; and (3) aphasic individuals demonstrating similar severity levels of language impairment show similar performance patterns for these types of processing tasks, despite locus of lesion or coexistence of apraxia of speech.
在4例获得性“纯”言语失用症患者、10例获得性失语症患者、10例失语症合并言语失用症患者以及11名神经功能正常的成年人中,对非言语和言语听觉处理技能以及内部言语处理技能进行了评估。实施了14项任务,并使用非参数和参数分析对68个变量的表现进行了检查,以控制年龄增长和相关听力损失的影响。在所有情况下,“纯”失用症患者的表现与正常受试者相同。在失语症和失语症 - 失用症受试者的表现之间几乎没有发现差异。结果得出三个主要结论:(1)言语失用症是一种与失语症不同的障碍;(2)失语症患者,无论病变部位如何,在处理听觉呈现的非言语和言语材料以及分析评估内部诱发的言语方面都存在障碍;(3)尽管病变部位或言语失用症共存,但表现出相似语言损伤严重程度的失语症患者在这些类型的处理任务中表现出相似的模式。