Dietz Isabel, Plog Anke, Jox Ralf J, Schulz Christian
1 Department of Palliative Medicine, Ludwig-Maximilian-University , Munich, Germany .
J Palliat Med. 2014 Mar;17(3):331-7. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2013.0356. Epub 2014 Feb 4.
Patient safety is a concern in medicine, and the prevention of medical errors remains a challenge. The definition and understanding of an error is particularly difficult in palliative care, with scarce empirical evidence about the nature and causes of medical errors in that discipline.
This study explored incidents palliative care professionals perceive as typical errors in their practice, and descriptions of such events.
In the context of an exploratory, cross-sectional survey on errors in palliative care among professionals of palliative care institutions in Bavaria, Germany (n=168), participants described a typical case in which an error occurred. Data from free-text answers was qualitatively analyzed, and categories for areas and causes of errors were extracted.
The questionnaire was returned by 42% (n=70) of the sample. Two-thirds of respondents (n=46, 66%) gave a free-text answer describing a typical error in palliative care. Seven potential areas for errors were identified in the qualitative analysis: drug treatment, palliative sedation, communication, care organization, treatment plan, end-of-life care, and history taking. Six categories emerged as causes of errors: miscommunication, system failure, dysfunctional attitudes, lack of knowledge, wrong use of technology, and misjudgement.
Data showed that medical errors in palliative care, as seen by professionals in the field, primarily affect medication and communication, and miscommunication and system failures are perceived as the leading causes of errors. A better understanding of the characteristics of errors within palliative care and further qualitative research are warranted to prevent errors and enhance patient safety.
患者安全是医学领域关注的问题,预防医疗差错仍然是一项挑战。在姑息治疗中,差错的定义和理解尤其困难,关于该学科医疗差错的性质和原因的实证证据很少。
本研究探讨了姑息治疗专业人员在其实践中认为是典型差错的事件以及对此类事件的描述。
在德国巴伐利亚州姑息治疗机构专业人员中进行的一项关于姑息治疗差错的探索性横断面调查(n = 168)中,参与者描述了一个发生差错的典型案例。对自由文本答案的数据进行了定性分析,并提取了差错领域和原因的类别。
样本中有42%(n = 70)返回了问卷。三分之二的受访者(n = 46,66%)给出了自由文本答案,描述了姑息治疗中的典型差错。在定性分析中确定了七个潜在的差错领域:药物治疗、姑息性镇静、沟通、护理组织、治疗计划、临终关怀和病史采集。出现了六个差错原因类别:沟通失误、系统故障、态度不当、知识缺乏、技术使用错误和判断失误。
数据表明,该领域专业人员所认为的姑息治疗中的医疗差错主要影响药物治疗和沟通,沟通失误和系统故障被视为差错的主要原因。有必要更好地了解姑息治疗中差错的特征并进行进一步的定性研究,以预防差错并提高患者安全。