Miller James S, Mhalu Aisa, Chalamilla Guerino, Siril Hellen, Kaaya Silvia, Tito Justina, Aris Eric, Hirschhorn Lisa R
a Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School , Boston , MA , USA.
AIDS Care. 2014;26(9):1150-4. doi: 10.1080/09540121.2014.882487. Epub 2014 Feb 6.
Health system responsiveness (HSR) measures quality of care from the patient's perspective, an important component of ensuring adherence to medication and care among HIV patients. We examined HSR in private clinics serving HIV patients in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. We surveyed 640 patients, 18 or older receiving care at one of 10 participating clinics, examining socioeconomic factors, HIV regimen, and self-reported experience with access and care at the clinic. Ordered logistic regression, adjusted for clustering of the clinic sites, was used to measure the relationships between age, gender, education, site size, and overall quality of care rating, as well as between the different HSR domains and overall rating. Overall, patients reported high levels of satisfaction with care received. Confidentiality, communication, and respect were particularly highly rated, while timeliness received lower ratings despite relatively short wait times, perhaps indicating high expectations when receiving care at a private clinic. Respect, confidentiality, and promptness were significantly associated with overall rating of health care, while provider skills and communication were not significantly associated. Patients reported that quality of service and confidentiality, rather than convenience of location, were the most important factors in their choice of a clinic. Site size (patient volume) was also positively correlated with patient satisfaction. Our findings suggest that, in the setting of urban private-sector clinics, flexible clinics hours, prompt services, and efforts to improve respect, privacy and confidentiality may prove more helpful in increasing visit adherence than geographic accessibility. While a responsive health system is valuable in its own right, more work is needed to confirm that improvements in HSR in fact lead to improved adherence to care.
卫生系统响应性(HSR)从患者角度衡量医疗服务质量,这是确保HIV患者坚持用药和接受治疗的一个重要组成部分。我们在坦桑尼亚达累斯萨拉姆为HIV患者提供服务的私立诊所中考察了HSR。我们对640名年龄在18岁及以上、在10家参与研究的诊所之一接受治疗的患者进行了调查,考察了社会经济因素、HIV治疗方案以及患者自我报告的在诊所获得服务和接受治疗的体验。使用经诊所地点聚类调整的有序逻辑回归来衡量年龄、性别、教育程度、诊所规模与总体医疗服务质量评级之间的关系,以及不同HSR领域与总体评级之间的关系。总体而言,患者对所接受的治疗满意度较高。保密性、沟通和尊重方面的评价尤其高,而及时性尽管等待时间相对较短,但评分较低,这可能表明在私立诊所接受治疗时患者期望较高。尊重、保密性和及时性与医疗服务的总体评级显著相关,而医护人员技能和沟通与总体评级无显著关联。患者报告称,服务质量和保密性而非地理位置的便利性是他们选择诊所的最重要因素。诊所规模(患者数量)也与患者满意度呈正相关。我们的研究结果表明,在城市私立诊所环境中,灵活的门诊时间、及时的服务以及在提高尊重、隐私和保密性方面所做的努力,可能比地理位置的便利性在提高就诊依从性方面更有帮助。虽然响应性良好的卫生系统本身很有价值,但还需要更多工作来证实HSR的改善实际上会导致治疗依从性的提高。