Middleton Aves, Gunn Jane, Bassilios Bridget, Pirkis Jane
General Practice and Primary Health Care Academic Centre, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
J Telemed Telecare. 2014 Mar;20(2):89-98. doi: 10.1177/1357633X14524156. Epub 2014 Feb 11.
We conducted a systematic review of research into callers making multiple calls to crisis helplines. Two databases were searched, identifying 561 articles from 1960 until 2012, of which 63 were relevant. Twenty-one articles from 19 separate studies presented empirical data about callers making multiple calls to crisis helplines. Of the 19 studies, three were intervention studies, five were surveys of callers and 11 were call record audits. Most studies were conducted in the USA and defined frequent callers as people making two or more calls. Frequent callers were more likely to be male and unmarried compared to other callers. There were no reported differences between frequent callers and other callers with regard to age, mental health conditions or suicidality. Three studies tested interventions designed to better manage frequent callers. These studies, even though small, reported reductions in the number of calls made by frequent callers. Suggested techniques for responding to frequent callers included: limiting the number and duration of calls allowed, assigning a specific counsellor, implementing face to face contact, the service initiating contact with the caller instead of waiting for callers to contact the service, providing short term anxiety and depression treatment programmes by telephone, and creating a specific management plan for each frequent caller. Future work requires robust study design methods using larger sample sizes and validated measurements.
我们对拨打危机求助热线多次的来电者相关研究进行了系统综述。检索了两个数据库,从1960年至2012年共识别出561篇文章,其中63篇相关。来自19项独立研究的21篇文章呈现了关于拨打危机求助热线多次的来电者的实证数据。在这19项研究中,3项为干预研究,5项为来电者调查,11项为通话记录审计。大多数研究在美国进行,将频繁来电者定义为拨打两次或更多次电话的人。与其他来电者相比,频繁来电者更可能为男性且未婚。在年龄、心理健康状况或自杀倾向方面,频繁来电者与其他来电者之间未报告有差异。3项研究测试了旨在更好管理频繁来电者的干预措施。这些研究尽管规模较小,但报告称频繁来电者的通话次数有所减少。针对频繁来电者的建议应对技巧包括:限制允许的通话次数和时长、指定特定的咨询师、进行面对面接触、服务主动联系来电者而非等待来电者联系服务、通过电话提供短期焦虑和抑郁治疗项目,以及为每个频繁来电者制定特定的管理计划。未来的工作需要采用更大样本量和经过验证的测量方法的稳健研究设计。