Scheeringa Michael S, Cobham Vanessa E, McDermott Brett
1 Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Tulane University , New Orleans, Louisiana.
J Child Adolesc Psychopharmacol. 2014 Feb;24(1):39-46. doi: 10.1089/cap.2013.0067.
Large, programmatic mental health intervention programs for children and adolescents following disasters have become increasingly common; however, little has been written about the key goals and challenges involved.
Using available data and the authors' experiences, this article reviews the factors involved in planning and implementing large-scale treatment programs following disasters.
These issues include funding, administration, choice of clinical targets, workforce selection, choice of treatment modalities, training, outcome monitoring, and consumer uptake. Ten factors are suggested for choosing among treatment modalities: 1) reach (providing access to the greatest number), 2) retention of patients, 3) privacy, 4) parental involvement, 5) familiarity of the modality to clinicians, 6) intensity (intervention type matches symptom acuity and impairment of patient), 7) burden to the clinician (in terms of time, travel, and inconvenience), 8) cost, 9) technology needs, and 10) effect size. Traditionally, after every new disaster, local leaders who have never done so before have had to be recruited to design, administer, and implement programs.
As expertise in all of these areas represents a gap for most local professionals in disaster-affected areas, we propose that a central, nongovernmental agency with national or international scope be created that can consult flexibly with local leaders following disasters on both overarching and specific issues. We propose recommendations and point out areas in greatest need of innovation.
针对儿童和青少年在灾难后的大型心理健康干预项目日益普遍;然而,关于其中涉及的关键目标和挑战的著述却很少。
利用现有数据和作者的经验,本文回顾了灾难后规划和实施大规模治疗项目所涉及的因素。
这些问题包括资金、管理、临床目标的选择、工作人员的选拔、治疗方式的选择、培训、结果监测以及消费者的接受度。文中提出了在治疗方式中进行选择的十个因素:1)覆盖面(能惠及最多的人),2)患者留存率,3)隐私性,4)家长参与度,5)临床医生对该治疗方式的熟悉程度,6)强度(干预类型与患者的症状严重程度和功能损害相匹配),7)对临床医生的负担(在时间、行程和不便程度方面),8)成本,9)技术需求,10)效应量。传统上,每次新灾难发生后,都不得不招募此前从未开展过此类工作的当地领导来设计、管理和实施项目。
由于所有这些领域的专业知识对受灾地区的大多数当地专业人员来说都存在差距,我们建议设立一个具有国家或国际范围的中央非政府机构,该机构能够在灾难发生后就总体问题和具体问题与当地领导进行灵活协商。我们提出了建议并指出了最需要创新的领域。