Oosthuizen J C, McShane D, Kinsella J, Conlon B
The Adelaide and Meath, Incorporating the National Children's Hospital, Dublin, Ireland,
Ir J Med Sci. 2015 Mar;184(1):143-6. doi: 10.1007/s11845-014-1075-6. Epub 2014 Feb 14.
During 2009, there were 3.3 million outpatient attendances at outpatient clinics across Ireland. Up to 20 % of these are directed towards ENT services.
To determine the compliance rate of general practitioners with the ICGP referral guidelines.
One-hundred referrals received were compared to the ICGP standardised form and graded accordingly. Each referral letter was graded to a maximum of 37 points.
The average score recorded for referrals was 16/37. The referrer detail section scored the highest with a mean of 75.42 % (paediatric referrals) and 72.9 % (adult referrals). The clinical information provided demonstrated compliance rates of 34 % (paediatrics) and 35 % (adults). In total, only 32 letters made any reference to findings on examination. Both paediatric and adult referrals scored an average of 42 % when patients' details are considered.
This study demonstrates poor compliance rates with the introduced ICGP standardised referral form, which has implications for the accurate grading of referral letters received.
2009年期间,爱尔兰各地门诊诊所的门诊就诊人次达330万。其中高达20%的就诊是针对耳鼻喉科服务的。
确定全科医生对爱尔兰全科医生协会(ICGP)转诊指南的遵守率。
将收到的100份转诊与ICGP标准化表格进行比较,并据此评分。每封转诊信的最高评分为37分。
转诊记录的平均得分为16/37。转诊人详细信息部分得分最高,儿科转诊的平均分是75.42%,成人转诊的平均分是72.9%。所提供的临床信息显示,儿科的遵守率为34%,成人的遵守率为35%。总共只有32封信提到了检查结果。考虑患者详细信息时,儿科和成人转诊的平均得分均为42%。
本研究表明,对引入的ICGP标准化转诊表格的遵守率很低,这对所收到转诊信的准确评分有影响。