Yurube Takashi, Sumi Masatoshi, Nishida Kotaro, Miyamoto Hiroshi, Kohyama Kozo, Matsubara Tsukasa, Miura Yasushi, Hirata Hiroaki, Sugiyama Daisuke, Doita Minoru
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine, Chuo-ku, Kobe, Japan.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Kobe Rosai Hospital, Chuo-ku, Kobe, Japan.
PLoS One. 2014 Feb 18;9(2):e88970. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0088970. eCollection 2014.
To clarify the incidence and predictive risk factors of cervical spine instabilities which may induce compression myelopathy in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
Three types of cervical spine instability were radiographically categorized into "moderate" and "severe" based on atlantoaxial subluxation (AAS: atlantodental interval >3 mm versus ≥10 mm), vertical subluxation (VS: Ranawat value <13 mm versus ≤10 mm), and subaxial subluxation (SAS: irreducible translation ≥2 mm versus ≥4 mm or at multiple). 228 "definite" or "classical" RA patients (140 without instability and 88 with "moderate" instability) were prospectively followed for >5 years. The endpoint incidence of "severe" instabilities and predictors for "severe" instability were determined.
Patients with baseline "moderate" instability, including all sub-groups (AAS(+) [VS(-) SAS(-)], VS(+) [SAS(-) AAS(±)], and SAS(+) [AAS(±) VS(±)]), developed "severe" instabilities more frequently (33.3% with AAS(+), 75.0% with VS(+), and 42.9% with SAS(+)) than those initially without instability (12.9%; p<0.003, p<0.003, and p = 0.061, respectively). The incidence of cervical canal stenosis and/or basilar invagination was also higher in patients with initial instability (17.5% with AAS(+), 37.5% with VS(+), and 14.3% with SAS(+)) than in those without instability (7.1%; p = 0.028, p<0.003, and p = 0.427, respectively). Multivariable logistic regression analysis identified corticosteroid administration, Steinbrocker stage III or IV at baseline, mutilating changes at baseline, and the development of mutilans during the follow-up period correlated with the progression to "severe" instability (p<0.05).
This prospective cohort study demonstrates accelerated development of cervical spine involvement in RA patients with pre-existing instability--especially VS. Advanced peripheral erosiveness and concomitant corticosteroid treatment are indicators for poor prognosis of the cervical spine in RA.
明确类风湿关节炎(RA)患者中可能导致压迫性脊髓病的颈椎不稳的发生率及预测风险因素。
根据寰枢椎半脱位(AAS:寰齿间距>3mm对≥10mm)、垂直半脱位(VS:Ranawat值<13mm对≤10mm)和下颈椎半脱位(SAS:不可复位移位≥2mm对≥4mm或多处移位),将三种类型的颈椎不稳在影像学上分为“中度”和“重度”。对228例“明确”或“典型”的RA患者(140例无颈椎不稳,88例有“中度”颈椎不稳)进行了超过5年的前瞻性随访。确定了“重度”颈椎不稳的终点发生率及“重度”颈椎不稳的预测因素。
基线时存在“中度”颈椎不稳的患者,包括所有亚组(AAS(+) [VS(-) SAS(-)]、VS(+) [SAS(-) AAS(±)]和SAS(+) [AAS(±) VS(±)]),发生“重度”颈椎不稳的频率(AAS(+)组为33.3%,VS(+)组为75.0%,SAS(+)组为42.9%)高于初始无颈椎不稳的患者(12.9%;p<0.003、p<0.003和p = 0.061)。初始有颈椎不稳的患者中颈椎管狭窄和/或基底凹陷的发生率(AAS(+)组为17.5%,VS(+)组为37.5%,SAS(+)组为14.3%)也高于无颈椎不稳的患者(7.1%;p = 0.028、p<0.003和p = 0.427)。多变量逻辑回归分析确定,使用皮质类固醇、基线时Steinbrocker III或IV期、基线时的毁损性改变以及随访期间致残性关节炎的发生与进展为“重度”颈椎不稳相关(p<0.05)。
这项前瞻性队列研究表明,已有颈椎不稳(尤其是VS)的RA患者颈椎受累发展加速。外周侵蚀严重及同时接受皮质类固醇治疗是RA患者颈椎预后不良的指标。