Andreotti Jennifer, Jann Kay, Melie-Garcia Lester, Giezendanner Stéphanie, Dierks Thomas, Federspiel Andrea
1 Department of Psychiatric Neurophysiology, University Hospital of Psychiatry , University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland .
Brain Connect. 2014 Apr;4(3):203-20. doi: 10.1089/brain.2013.0202. Epub 2014 Apr 7.
Computational network analysis provides new methods to analyze the human connectome. Brain structural networks can be characterized by global and local metrics that recently gave promising insights for diagnosis and further understanding of neurological, psychiatric, and neurodegenerative disorders. In order to ensure the validity of results in clinical settings, the precision and repeatability of the networks and the associated metrics must be evaluated. In the present study, 19 healthy subjects underwent two consecutive measurements enabling us to test reproducibility of the brain network and its global and local metrics. As it is known that the network topology depends on the network density, the effects of setting a common density threshold for all networks were also assessed. Results showed good to excellent repeatability for global metrics, while for local metrics it was more variable and some metrics were found to have locally poor repeatability. Moreover, between-subjects differences were slightly inflated when the density was not fixed. At the global level, these findings confirm previous results on the validity of global network metrics as clinical biomarkers. However, the new results in our work indicate that the remaining variability at the local level as well as the effect of methodological characteristics on the network topology should be considered in the analysis of brain structural networks and especially in network comparisons.
计算网络分析为分析人类连接组提供了新方法。脑结构网络可以通过全局和局部指标来表征,这些指标最近为神经、精神和神经退行性疾病的诊断及进一步理解提供了有前景的见解。为了确保临床环境中结果的有效性,必须评估网络及其相关指标的精度和可重复性。在本研究中,19名健康受试者接受了连续两次测量,这使我们能够测试脑网络及其全局和局部指标的可重复性。由于已知网络拓扑取决于网络密度,因此还评估了为所有网络设置共同密度阈值的影响。结果显示全局指标具有良好到优异的可重复性,而局部指标的可重复性更具变异性,并且发现一些指标在局部的可重复性较差。此外,当密度不固定时,个体间差异会略有夸大。在全局层面,这些发现证实了先前关于全局网络指标作为临床生物标志物有效性的结果。然而,我们工作中的新结果表明,在分析脑结构网络尤其是网络比较时,应考虑局部层面剩余的变异性以及方法学特征对网络拓扑的影响。