Lu Yao, Paraskevopoulos Evangelos, Herholz Sibylle C, Kuchenbuch Anja, Pantev Christo
Institute for Biomagnetism and Biosignalanalysis, University of Münster, Münster, Germany.
German Center for Neurodegenerative Diseases, Bonn, Germany.
PLoS One. 2014 Mar 3;9(3):e90686. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0090686. eCollection 2014.
Numerous studies have demonstrated that the structural and functional differences between professional musicians and non-musicians are not only found within a single modality, but also with regard to multisensory integration. In this study we have combined psychophysical with neurophysiological measurements investigating the processing of non-musical, synchronous or various levels of asynchronous audiovisual events. We hypothesize that long-term multisensory experience alters temporal audiovisual processing already at a non-musical stage. Behaviorally, musicians scored significantly better than non-musicians in judging whether the auditory and visual stimuli were synchronous or asynchronous. At the neural level, the statistical analysis for the audiovisual asynchronous response revealed three clusters of activations including the ACC and the SFG and two bilaterally located activations in IFG and STG in both groups. Musicians, in comparison to the non-musicians, responded to synchronous audiovisual events with enhanced neuronal activity in a broad left posterior temporal region that covers the STG, the insula and the Postcentral Gyrus. Musicians also showed significantly greater activation in the left Cerebellum, when confronted with an audiovisual asynchrony. Taken together, our MEG results form a strong indication that long-term musical training alters the basic audiovisual temporal processing already in an early stage (direct after the auditory N1 wave), while the psychophysical results indicate that musical training may also provide behavioral benefits in the accuracy of the estimates regarding the timing of audiovisual events.
众多研究表明,专业音乐家与非音乐家之间的结构和功能差异不仅存在于单一模态中,在多感官整合方面也有所体现。在本研究中,我们将心理物理学测量与神经生理学测量相结合,研究非音乐性的、同步或不同程度异步视听事件的处理过程。我们假设,长期的多感官体验会在非音乐阶段就改变视听时间处理。在行为层面,在判断听觉和视觉刺激是同步还是异步时,音乐家的得分显著高于非音乐家。在神经层面,对视听异步反应的统计分析显示,两组均有三个激活簇,包括前扣带回和额上回,以及在额下回和颞上回两侧的两个激活区域。与非音乐家相比,音乐家在一个广泛的左后颞区对同步视听事件的反应表现为神经元活动增强,该区域覆盖颞上回、脑岛和中央后回。当面对视听不同步时,音乐家在左小脑的激活也明显更强。综上所述,我们的脑磁图结果有力地表明,长期的音乐训练在早期阶段(直接在听觉N1波之后)就改变了基本的视听时间处理,而心理物理学结果表明,音乐训练在视听事件时间估计的准确性方面也可能带来行为上的益处。