Agha Riaz A, Gundogan Buket, Fowler Alexander J, Bragg Thomas W H, Orgill Dennis P
Department of Plastic Surgery, Stoke Mandeville Hospital, Aylesbury, UK.
BMJ Open. 2014 Mar 12;4(3):e004253. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-004253.
The Cook-Swartz implantable Doppler monitors venous or arterial blood flow from free flaps and can detect free-flap compromise. Previous studies have shown that the use of this Doppler can improve detection and salvage rates as it provides an earlier warning than the current method of clinical assessment. Such studies assert that the implantable Doppler is of great value in monitoring free flaps in current microsurgical units. This systematic review aims to compare the efficacy of the Cook-Swartz implantable Doppler in monitoring free-flap compromise against conventional clinical free-flap monitoring techniques.
Various electronic databases will be systematically searched for studies that compare the use of Cook-Swartz implantable Doppler with clinical assessment. The selected studies will then have their titles and abstracts screened by two authors. Articles selected after title and abstract screen will have full text downloaded and the complete article will be assessed for suitability. Once the articles have been selected for inclusion, data extraction will take place. For data analysis, the outcomes of the studies will be tabulated, with descriptive statistics performed as appropriate and the detection rate of the Doppler and clinical assessment will be compared and synthesised where possible.
The authors hope to disseminate the findings as widely as possible. This systematic review will be published in a peer-reviewed journal and include a number of recommendations as its conclusion based on the evidence contained within. Given the wide range of specialties now utilising flaps, it will be presented at a wide range of national and international conferences.
CRD42013005818 The literature search and data extraction went on until 28 January 2014. These steps were revised in line with peer review comments.
库克 - 施瓦茨植入式多普勒仪可监测游离皮瓣的静脉或动脉血流,并能检测游离皮瓣是否出现问题。先前的研究表明,使用这种多普勒仪可提高检测率和挽救率,因为它比目前的临床评估方法能更早发出预警。此类研究断言,在当前显微外科手术单元中,植入式多普勒仪在监测游离皮瓣方面具有重要价值。本系统评价旨在比较库克 - 施瓦茨植入式多普勒仪与传统临床游离皮瓣监测技术在监测游离皮瓣问题方面的疗效。
将系统检索各种电子数据库,以查找比较库克 - 施瓦茨植入式多普勒仪与临床评估使用情况的研究。然后由两位作者对所选研究的标题和摘要进行筛选。标题和摘要筛选后入选的文章将下载全文,并对全文进行适用性评估。一旦选定纳入文章,将进行数据提取。对于数据分析,将把研究结果制成表格,酌情进行描述性统计,并在可能的情况下比较和综合多普勒仪与临床评估的检测率。
作者希望尽可能广泛地传播研究结果。本系统评价将发表在同行评审期刊上,并根据其中包含的证据在结论中提出一些建议。鉴于目前使用皮瓣的专业领域广泛,该研究将在众多国内和国际会议上展示。
在国际前瞻性系统评价注册库(PROSPERO)中的方案注册号:CRD42013005818 文献检索和数据提取持续至2014年1月28日。这些步骤根据同行评审意见进行了修订。