Alhilali L, Reynolds A R, Fakhran S
From the Department of Radiology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2014 Jul;35(7):1405-11. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A3879. Epub 2014 Mar 13.
Our aim was to compare the CT and PET/CT imaging features of osteoradionecrosis with those of recurrent disease after treatment of head and neck malignancy.
We retrospectively reviewed maxillofacial and neck CT scans obtained for suspected osteoradionecrosis or tumor recurrence for the presence of the following: 1) discrete solid mass, 2) cystic mass, 3) interruption of the bony cortex, 4) bony fragmentation, 5) bony trabecular loss, 6) intraosseous gas, and 7) bony sclerosis. Trabecular bone loss was further categorized as permeative (<75% loss of trabecula) or lucent (>75% loss). PET/CT studies performed for suspected osteoradionecrosis or tumor recurrence were evaluated for mean standard uptake value and maximum standard uptake value.
Ten maxillofacial CT, 53 neck CT, and 23 PET/CT studies were performed in 63 patients. Osteoradionecrosis was diagnosed by pathology or imaging stability in 46 patients, and tumor recurrence, in 17 patients. Bony sclerosis was found to be significantly more prevalent in osteoradionecrosis and was never seen with tumor recurrence (P = .013). Patients with tumor recurrence were more likely to have a solid (P < .001) or cystic mass (P = .025), which was rare in osteoradionecrosis. While patients with tumor recurrence had significantly higher mean standard uptake values and maximum standard uptake values, there was significant overlap in mean standard uptake values and maximum standard uptake values between the 2 groups.
There is significant overlap of standard uptake values in patients with osteoradionecrosis and tumor recurrence. CT findings provide more reliable diagnostic tools, with a solid or cystic mass strongly associated with tumor recurrence and bony sclerosis seen only with osteoradionecrosis.
我们的目的是比较放射性骨坏死与头颈部恶性肿瘤治疗后复发疾病的CT及PET/CT影像特征。
我们回顾性分析了因疑似放射性骨坏死或肿瘤复发而进行的颌面及颈部CT扫描,观察是否存在以下情况:1)离散实性肿块;2)囊性肿块;3)骨皮质中断;4)骨碎片;5)骨小梁缺失;6)骨内气体;7)骨质硬化。骨小梁缺失进一步分为弥漫性(小梁缺失<75%)或透亮性(小梁缺失>75%)。对因疑似放射性骨坏死或肿瘤复发而进行的PET/CT研究评估其平均标准摄取值和最大标准摄取值。
63例患者共进行了10次颌面CT、53次颈部CT及23次PET/CT检查。46例患者经病理或影像稳定性诊断为放射性骨坏死,17例为肿瘤复发。发现骨质硬化在放射性骨坏死中显著更常见,而肿瘤复发中从未见(P = 0.013)。肿瘤复发患者更可能有实性肿块(P < 0.001)或囊性肿块(P = 0.025),这在放射性骨坏死中少见。虽然肿瘤复发患者的平均标准摄取值和最大标准摄取值显著更高,但两组间平均标准摄取值和最大标准摄取值有显著重叠。
放射性骨坏死和肿瘤复发患者的标准摄取值有显著重叠。CT表现提供了更可靠的诊断工具,实性或囊性肿块与肿瘤复发密切相关,骨质硬化仅见于放射性骨坏死。