Kitchens Brandon, Wells Martha, Tantbirojn Daranee, Versluis Antheunis
Department of Pediatric Dentistry, College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Memphis, TN, USA.
Int J Paediatr Dent. 2015 Mar;25(2):79-86. doi: 10.1111/ipd.12102. Epub 2014 Mar 17.
To determine whether recommended short curing times of three high-power light emitting diode (LED) curing lights are sufficient to polymerize sealant materials.
Opaque-unfilled sealant (Delton LC Opaque), opaque-filled sealant (UltraSeal XT plus), and clear-filled sealant (FluroShield) were light cured in a covered slot-mold using the manufacturers' shortest recommended curing times with three high-power LED lights (3-s VALO, 5-s Fusion, 10-s Smartlite). A 40-s cure with a quartz-tungsten halogen (QTH) light was used as control. Vickers hardness was measured 24 h after curing at the sealant surface and through the depth (0.5 mm increments) (N = 10). Results were analyzed with two-way anova (pair-wise multiple comparisons, significance level 0.05).
The high-power LEDs did not cure the sealants as deep as the QTH. Delton LC Opaque showed the least depth of cure as hardness values beyond a depth of 0.5 mm were not measurable regardless of the curing light. Even for UltraSeal XT plus, when surface hardness was about the same with all lights, hardness decreased more rapidly with depth for the LEDs. FluroShield showed the slowest decline in hardness through the depth for all lights.
Manufacturers' recommendations for shortest possible curing time with high-power LEDs were not sufficient for adequate polymerization of the tested sealants.
确定三种高功率发光二极管(LED)固化灯推荐的短固化时间是否足以使封闭剂材料聚合。
使用三种高功率LED灯(3秒的VALO、5秒的Fusion、10秒的Smartlite),按照制造商推荐的最短固化时间,在有盖的缝隙模具中对不透明未填充封闭剂(Delton LC Opaque)、不透明填充封闭剂(UltraSeal XT plus)和透明填充封闭剂(FluroShield)进行光固化。以石英钨卤素(QTH)灯40秒的固化作为对照。固化24小时后,在封闭剂表面及整个深度(以0.5毫米递增)测量维氏硬度(N = 10)。结果采用双向方差分析(两两多重比较,显著性水平0.05)进行分析。
高功率LED对封闭剂的固化深度不如QTH灯。Delton LC Opaque显示出最小的固化深度,因为无论使用何种固化灯,超过0.5毫米深度的硬度值都无法测量。即使对于UltraSeal XT plus,当所有灯照射后表面硬度大致相同时,LED照射下硬度随深度下降得更快。对于所有灯,FluroShield在整个深度上硬度下降最慢。
制造商推荐的高功率LED最短固化时间不足以使测试的封闭剂充分聚合。