Desalu O O, Onyedum C C, Adeoti A O, Ozoh O B, Sogaolu O, Gunduri L B, Adekoya A O, Salami A K, Fawibe A E
Department of Medicine ,University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital ,Ilorin. Nigeria.
Niger Postgrad Med J. 2013 Dec;20(4):291-8.
The objective of this study was to determine the factors that affect the interest in respiratory medicine (RM) as a subspecialty of choice among internal medicine residents in Nigeria.
SUBJECTS, MATERIALS AND METHODS: This was a cross-sectional study of 136 internal medicine residents recruited from seven teaching hospitals from January 2011 to June 2011. A semi-structured questionnaire that was self administered by residents was used to obtain socio-demographic information and factors affecting residents' interest in respiratory medicine.
Out of 136 residents that completed the study, 78 (57.4 %) were junior residents (PG year 1-3) and 58(42.6%) were senior residents (PG year >3). Thirty four (43.6%) junior residents and 21(36.2%) senior residents considered respiratory medicine as a sub-specialty of choice. Only 2(3.5%) of the senior residents were presently committed to RM. In the junior residents, interest in respiratory medicine was correlated with personal intelligence and ability (RR=2.58, ;95% confidence interval(CI): 1.16-7.07, p-0.01) , availability of respiratory physician (RR=2.42; 95% CI 1.07-7.63 ,p-0.02) and postgraduate examiners in RM in training institutions RR= (2.20; 95% CI 1.06-5.45,p-0.03), experience during rotation in medical school and residency (RR=2.11 ; 95% CI 1.11-4.21,p-0.03) and future annual income (RR=2.04;C:I1.03-4.68,p-0.04). In the senior residents, interest in RM was correlated with the availability of postgraduate examiners in RM in training institutions (RR- 6.36; 95% CI 1.16-66.80, P-<0.01), future opportunity for scholarships and travel grants (RR- 4.23; 95% CI 1.19-25.92,p-< 0.01), personal intelligence and ability (RR= 3.41; 95% CI.16-13.87,p-0.01) and prospect for rapid elevation in career (RR=2.92; 95% CI 1.03-11.91,p -0.04). Provisions of modern facilities in training institutions, mentoring by senior colleagues and promotion of subspecialty by respiratory physicians were rated by the senior residents as the most important ways of increasing interest in respiratory medicine and making it a specialty of choice.
The interest in respiratory medicine among internal medicine residents is low and decline as their level of training advances. The factors affecting the interest in respiratory medicine have been highlighted and the policy makers need to understand, and if possible modify these factors by formulating appropriate changes to our training programs so as to increase future numbers of respiratory physician.
本研究的目的是确定影响尼日利亚内科住院医师将呼吸医学作为专科选择兴趣的因素。
研究对象、材料与方法:这是一项横断面研究,于2011年1月至2011年6月从七家教学医院招募了136名内科住院医师。采用由住院医师自行填写的半结构化问卷来获取社会人口学信息以及影响住院医师对呼吸医学兴趣的因素。
在完成研究的136名住院医师中,78名(57.4%)为初级住院医师(研究生第1 - 3年),58名(42.6%)为高级住院医师(研究生第3年以上)。34名(43.6%)初级住院医师和21名(36.2%)高级住院医师将呼吸医学视为专科选择。目前仅有2名(3.5%)高级住院医师致力于呼吸医学。在初级住院医师中,对呼吸医学的兴趣与个人智力和能力相关(相对风险度RR = 2.58;95%置信区间CI:1.16 - 7.07,p = 0.01)、呼吸内科医师的可获得性(RR = 2.42;95% CI 1.07 - 7.63,p = 0.02)以及培训机构中呼吸医学研究生考官的情况(RR = 2.20;95% CI 1.06 - 5.45,p = 0.03)、医学院和住院医师轮转期间的经历(RR = 2.11;95% CI 1.11 - 4.21,p = 0.03)以及未来年收入(RR = 2.04;CI 1.03 - 4.68,p = 0.04)有关。在高级住院医师中,对呼吸医学的兴趣与培训机构中呼吸医学研究生考官的可获得性(RR = 6. .36;95% CI 1.16 - 66.80,P < 0.01)、未来获得奖学金和差旅补助的机会(RR = 4.23;95% CI 1.19 - 25.92,p < 0.01)个人智力和能力(RR = 3.41;95% CI 1.16 - 13.87,p = 0.01)以及职业快速晋升的前景(RR = 2.92;95% CI 1.03 - 11.91,p = 0.04)相关。高级住院医师认为,培训机构提供现代设施、资深同事的指导以及呼吸内科医师对专科的推广是提高对呼吸医学兴趣并使其成为专科选择的最重要方式。
内科住院医师对呼吸医学的兴趣较低,且随着培训水平提高而下降。已突出显示了影响对呼吸医学兴趣的因素,政策制定者需要了解这些因素,并尽可能通过对我们的培训计划进行适当调整来改变这些因素,以增加未来呼吸内科医师的数量。