Göttken Tanja, White Lars O, Klein Annette M, von Klitzing Kai
Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, University of Leipzig.
Psychotherapy (Chic). 2014 Mar;51(1):148-158. doi: 10.1037/a0036026.
Few studies report treatment outcome for early childhood internalizing disorders following psychotherapy, especially psychodynamic techniques. We aimed to investigate effectiveness of a novel, developmentally appropriate, short-term psychodynamic treatment program for 4- to 10-year-olds with anxiety disorders in an outpatient setting. We conducted a quasi-experimental wait-list controlled study. Thirty children (12 females) with Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) anxiety disorders and their families received 20-25 sessions of manualized short-term Psychoanalytic Child Therapy (PaCT). We assessed outcome with standardized diagnostic interviews and parent reports of internalizing and total problems at all time points. Child puppet interviews and teacher reports were also available for pre-post treatment and follow-up analyses. While 18 families entered treatment immediately, 12 families were first wait-listed before receiving treatment. Analyses of symptom improvement were based on comparisons between groups (treatment vs. wait-list) as well as pre-post and 6-month follow-up data across all families (including wait-listed families). Among the 27 completers, 66.67% (n = 18) no longer met criteria for any anxiety disorder (59.88% in intent-to-treat analysis) while no children remitted across the wait-list interval. Parent-reported child internalizing and total problems significantly declined during treatment relative to wait-list. Child and teacher reports also revealed significant pre-post symptom reductions on internalizing and total problems. Diagnostic and symptom remission rates were maintained at 6-month follow-up except on child reports. This preliminary study adds to a growing database showing that psychodynamic treatments may offer an effective line of treatment for childhood internalizing symptoms and disorders in the eyes of clinicians, children, parents, and teachers.
很少有研究报告心理治疗,尤其是心理动力学技术对幼儿内化性障碍的治疗效果。我们旨在调查一种针对门诊环境中患有焦虑症的4至10岁儿童的新型、适合其发育阶段的短期心理动力学治疗方案的有效性。我们进行了一项准实验性等待名单对照研究。30名患有精神疾病诊断与统计手册(DSM-IV)焦虑症的儿童(12名女性)及其家庭接受了20至25节手册化的短期儿童精神分析治疗(PaCT)。我们在所有时间点通过标准化诊断访谈和家长对内化问题及总问题的报告来评估治疗效果。还可获得儿童木偶访谈和教师报告用于治疗前后及随访分析。18个家庭立即开始治疗,12个家庭先被列入等待名单,之后再接受治疗。症状改善分析基于组间比较(治疗组与等待名单组)以及所有家庭(包括等待名单上的家庭)的治疗前后和6个月随访数据。在27名完成治疗的儿童中,66.67%(n = 18)不再符合任何焦虑症的标准(意向性分析中为59.88%),而等待名单组的儿童无一缓解。与等待名单组相比,治疗期间家长报告的儿童内化问题及总问题显著减少。儿童和教师报告也显示内化问题及总问题在治疗前后有显著的症状减轻。除了儿童报告外,诊断和症状缓解率在6个月随访时得以维持。这项初步研究增加了一个不断增长的数据库,表明在临床医生、儿童、家长和教师看来,心理动力学治疗可能为儿童内化症状和障碍提供一种有效的治疗方法。