Quinn Gene R, Le Elizabeth, Soni Krishan, Berger Gabrielle, Mak Y Erica, Pierce Read
Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf. 2014 Jan;40(1):30-8. doi: 10.1016/s1553-7250(14)40004-7.
Successful quality improvement is fundamental to high-performing health care systems, but becomes increasingly difficult as systems become more complex. Previous attempts at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) Medical Center to reduce door-to-floor (D2F) time -the time required to move an ill patient through the emergency department (ED) to an appropriate inpatient bed-had not resulted in meaningful improvement. An analysis of why attempts at decreasing D2F times in the ED had failed, with attention to contextual factors, yields recommendations on how to decrease D2F time.
A team of 11 internal medicine residents, in partnership with the Patient Flow Executive Steering Committee, performed a literature review, process mapping, and analysis of the admissions process. The team conducted interviews with medical center staff across disciplines, members of high-performing patient care units, and leaders of peer institutions who had undertaken similar efforts.
Each of the following three domains-(1) Improving Work Flow, (2) Changing Culture, and (3) Understanding Incentives-is independently an important source of resistance and opportunity. However, the improvement work and understanding of complexity science suggest that all three domains must be addressed simultaneously to effect meaningful change. Recommendations include eliminating redundant and frustrating processes; encouraging multidisciplinary collaboration; fostering trust between departments; providing feedback on individual performance; enhancing provider buy-in; and, ultimately, uniting staff behind a common goal.
By conceptualizing the hospital as a complex adaptive system, multiple interrelated groups can be encouraged to work together and accomplish a common goal.
成功的质量改进是高效医疗系统的基础,但随着系统变得越来越复杂,这一过程也变得愈发困难。此前,加利福尼亚大学旧金山分校(UCSF)医学中心曾尝试缩短患者从入院到安置(D2F)的时间,即让患病患者通过急诊科(ED)转移到合适的住院床位所需的时间,但未取得显著成效。通过分析急诊科缩短D2F时间的尝试为何失败,并关注相关背景因素,可得出关于如何缩短D2F时间的建议。
由11名内科住院医师组成的团队与患者流程执行指导委员会合作,进行了文献综述、流程映射以及对入院流程的分析。该团队采访了医学中心各学科的工作人员、高效患者护理单元的成员以及开展过类似工作的同行机构的负责人。
以下三个领域中的每一个——(1)改善工作流程,(2)改变文化,(3)理解激励措施——各自都是阻力和机遇的重要来源。然而,改进工作和对复杂性科学的理解表明,必须同时解决这三个领域的问题才能实现有意义的变革。建议包括消除冗余和令人沮丧的流程;鼓励多学科协作;促进部门间的信任;提供个人绩效反馈;增强医疗服务提供者的支持;最终,让全体员工为共同目标团结协作。
将医院视为一个复杂的自适应系统,可鼓励多个相互关联的群体共同努力并实现共同目标。