Tueni E A, Newman R A, Baker F L, Ajani J A, Fan D, Spitzer G
Department of Hematology, Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston 77030.
Cancer Res. 1989 Mar 1;49(5):1099-102.
The objective of this study was to compare the relative in vitro cytotoxicity of bleomycin to that of two newer-generation analogues, tallysomycin S10b and liblomycin. The latter compound is of particular interest as it has recently been shown in preclinical studies to be free of a potential to cause pulmonary injury and yet to possess only a minor potential to produce myelotoxicity. Using the adhesive tumor cell culture system, we evaluated the activity of these three drugs against a panel of 13 human tumors of various types. The range of concentrations chosen was determined and normalized using a nonleukemic permanent mouse hematopoietic progenitor cell line. Those drug concentrations achieving 90% inhibition of growth (IC90) against the murine cell line were: 6.11 microM bleomycin; 7.53 microM tallysomycin S10b; and 0.6 microM liblomycin. When tested against fresh human tumors at equally myelotoxic IC90 concentrations, bleomycin and tallysomycin S10b (nonmyelotoxic compounds) both achieved 90% growth inhibition of all tumors, while liblomycin (a myelotoxic compound) produced an IC90 inhibition in 69% of all tumors. A comparison of drug IC90 values against individual fresh tumors indicated a correlation between bleomycin and its structurally related analogue tallysomycin S10b. No such correlation, however, was seen with liblomycin in comparison to either bleomycin or tallysomycin S10b. The relative activity of liblomycin versus that of bleomycin and tallysomycin S10b varied with individual tumors tested. The response rate of liblomycin, a myelotoxic compound within this normalized range, appears promising. These data represent the first comparison of liblomycin to bleomycin against a spectrum of fresh human tumors using a stem cell assay technique.
