Psychiatry, Internal Medicine, Surgery, & Emergency Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, USA.
Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, USA.
Alcohol. 2014 Jun;48(4):375-90. doi: 10.1016/j.alcohol.2014.01.004. Epub 2014 Feb 19.
BACKGROUND: To date, no screening tools for alcohol withdrawal syndromes (AWS) have been validated in the medically ill. Although several tools quantify the severity of AWS (e.g., Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment for Alcohol [CIWA]), none identify subjects at risk of AWS, thus missing the opportunity for timely prophylaxis. Moreover, there are no validated tools for the prediction of complicated (i.e., moderate to severe) AWS in the medically ill. OBJECTIVES: Our goals were (1) to conduct a systematic review of the published literature on AWS to identify clinical factors associated with the development of AWS, (2) to use the identified factors to develop a tool for the prediction of alcohol withdrawal among patients at risk, and (3) to conduct a pilot study to assess the validity of the tool. METHODS: For the creation of the Prediction of Alcohol Withdrawal Severity Scale (PAWSS), we conducted a systematic literature search using PRISMA (preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses) guidelines for clinical factors associated with the development of AWS, using PubMed, PsychInfo, MEDLINE, and Cochrane Databases. Eligibility criteria included: (i) manuscripts dealing with human subjects, age 18 years or older, (ii) manuscripts directly addressing descriptions of AWS or its predisposing factors, including case reports, naturalistic case descriptions, and all types of clinical trials (e.g., randomized, single-blind, or open label studies), (iii) manuscripts describing characteristics of alcohol use disorder (AUD), and (iv) manuscripts dealing with animal data (which were considered only if they directly dealt with variables described in humans). Obtained data were used to develop the Prediction of Alcohol Withdrawal Severity Scale, in order to assist in the identification of patients at risk for complicated AWS. A pilot study was conducted to assess the new tool's psychometric qualities on patients admitted to a general inpatient medicine unit over a 2-week period, who agreed to participate in the study. Blind to PAWSS results, a separate group of researchers retrospectively examined the medical records for evidence of AWS. RESULTS: The search produced 2802 articles describing factors potentially associated with increased risk for AWS, increased severity of withdrawal symptoms, and potential characteristics differentiating subjects with various forms of AWS. Of these, 446 articles met inclusion criteria and underwent further scrutiny, yielding a total of 233 unique articles describing factors predictive of AWS. A total of 10 items were identified as correlated with complicated AWS (i.e., withdrawal hallucinosis, withdrawal-related seizures, and delirium tremens) and used to construct the PAWSS. During the pilot study, a total of 68 subjects underwent evaluation with PAWSS. In this pilot sample the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of PAWSS were 100%, using the threshold score of 4. DISCUSSION: The results of the literature search identified 10 items which may be correlated with risk for complicated AWS. These items were assembled into a tool to assist in the identification of patients at risk: PAWSS. The results of this pilot study suggest that PAWSS may be useful in identifying risk of complicated AWS in medically ill, hospitalized individuals. PAWSS is the first validated tool for the prediction of severe AWS in the medically ill and its use may aid in the early identification of patients at risk for complicated AWS, allowing for prophylaxis against AWS before severe alcohol withdrawal syndromes develop.
背景:迄今为止,尚未有针对酒精戒断综合征(AWS)的筛选工具在患病者中得到验证。尽管有几种工具可量化 AWS 的严重程度(例如临床酒精戒断评估量表 [CIWA]),但没有一种工具能够识别 AWS 风险患者,因此错失了及时预防的机会。此外,在患病者中,尚无用于预测复杂(即中度至重度)AWS 的经过验证的工具。
目的:我们的目标是:(1)对 AWS 文献进行系统综述,以确定与 AWS 发展相关的临床因素;(2)利用确定的因素开发一种针对高危人群的酒精戒断预测工具;(3)进行一项初步研究以评估该工具的有效性。
方法:为了创建酒精戒断严重程度预测量表(PAWSS),我们按照 PRISMA(系统评价和荟萃分析的首选报告项目)指南进行了系统文献检索,以确定与 AWS 发展相关的临床因素,检索使用了 PubMed、PsychInfo、MEDLINE 和 Cochrane 数据库。纳入标准包括:(i)涉及人类受试者的手稿,年龄 18 岁或以上;(ii)直接描述 AWS 或其诱发因素的手稿,包括病例报告、自然病例描述和各种类型的临床试验(例如,随机、单盲或开放标签研究);(iii)描述酒精使用障碍(AUD)特征的手稿;(iv)涉及动物数据的手稿(仅在它们直接涉及人类描述的变量时才考虑)。从获得的数据中开发了酒精戒断严重程度预测量表,以帮助识别有发生复杂 AWS 风险的患者。在为期两周的时间里,我们对入住综合住院内科的患者进行了一项初步研究,以评估新工具的心理测量学特性,患者同意参加该研究。另一组研究人员在不知道 PAWSS 结果的情况下,回顾性地检查了病历,以寻找 AWS 的证据。
结果:检索产生了 2802 篇描述可能增加 AWS 风险、戒断症状严重程度增加和潜在区分各种形式 AWS 的特征的文章。其中,446 篇文章符合纳入标准,并进行了进一步审查,共产生了 233 篇描述 AWS 预测因素的独特文章。共有 10 个项目被确定与复杂 AWS(即戒断性幻觉、戒断性癫痫发作和震颤性谵妄)相关,并用于构建 PAWSS。在初步研究中,共有 68 名患者接受了 PAWSS 评估。在该初步样本中,PAWSS 的敏感性、特异性、阳性和阴性预测值均为 100%,使用的截断分数为 4。
讨论:文献检索的结果确定了 10 个可能与复杂 AWS 风险相关的项目。这些项目被组合成一种工具,以帮助识别高危患者:PAWSS。这项初步研究的结果表明,PAWSS 可能有助于识别患有疾病的住院患者中复杂 AWS 的风险。PAWSS 是第一个针对患病者中严重 AWS 预测的经过验证的工具,其使用可能有助于早期识别发生复杂 AWS 的风险患者,在严重酒精戒断综合征发生之前进行预防。
Neuropsychopharmacol Hung. 2025-6
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2021-4-19
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2023-1-9
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020-10-19
Alcohol Clin Exp Res (Hoboken). 2025-1
JAMA Netw Open. 2024-10-1
Crit Care Explor. 2024-3-18