Benito María, Sánchez José Antonio, Codinha Sónia
School of Legal Medicine of Madrid, Complutense University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain,
Int J Legal Med. 2014 May;128(3):523-33. doi: 10.1007/s00414-014-0989-x. Epub 2014 Mar 25.
Age-at-death estimation in adult individuals is one of the most challenging issues in forensic anthropology, namely, due to the large age intervals provided by the current methods, which demand the development of more reliable investigations. The clavicle has been studied as an age-at-death indicator in many researches for its accessibility, low biomechanical implication in locomotion and accuracy to predict age at death when other age indicators are not available. The present study was developed on a sample of 332 clavicles from adult individuals of known sex and age from the current Spanish population. They were x-rayed and digitalized, in a standardized way, using a Sedecal X-ray generator, model SHF 415. Three indices were calculated at the mid-diaphysis point (anterior index, posterior index, and total index) which relate the cortical thickness and the total clavicle thickness to age at death. The average grey level was also calculated in a 0.5-cm(2) area of the sternal and acromial ends (sternal grey average, acromial grey average), using Image J software. The data were subjected to a statistical analysis, using SPSS, version 15.0. The results show that average grey level has a weaker correlation with age than the variables which are based on the cortical thickness. On the other hand, the regression equations, which were calculated combining all the variables, provided smaller age-at-death intervals, demonstrating the usefulness of this method for adult age-at-death estimation in forensic anthropology.
在法医人类学中,成年个体的死亡年龄估计是最具挑战性的问题之一,即由于当前方法提供的年龄区间较大,这就需要开展更可靠的研究。在许多研究中,锁骨因其易于获取、在运动中生物力学影响较小以及在其他年龄指标不可用时预测死亡年龄的准确性而被作为死亡年龄指标进行研究。本研究以来自当前西班牙人群中已知性别和年龄的332例成年个体的锁骨为样本展开。使用Sedecal SHF 415型X射线发生器以标准化方式对其进行X射线检查并数字化。在骨干中点计算了三个指数(前指数、后指数和总指数),这些指数将皮质厚度和锁骨总厚度与死亡年龄相关联。还使用Image J软件在胸骨端和肩峰端的0.5平方厘米区域计算了平均灰度值(胸骨平均灰度、肩峰平均灰度)。使用SPSS 15.0版本对数据进行统计分析。结果表明,平均灰度值与年龄的相关性比基于皮质厚度的变量弱。另一方面,结合所有变量计算出的回归方程给出了更小的死亡年龄区间,证明了该方法在法医人类学中对成年个体死亡年龄估计的有用性。