Zanchetta José R, Hakim Carina, Lombas Carola
Metabolic Research Institute, University of El Salvador School of Medicine, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Curr Ther Res Clin Exp. 2004 Nov;65(6):470-80. doi: 10.1016/j.curtheres.2005.01.003.
Abstract.
Medical practitioners face the challenge of noncompliance with prescriptions, particularly in chronic, asymptomatic, diseases such as osteoporosis.
The aim of this study was to assess the raloxifene compliance and continuance rates and adverse effects over 24 months in clinical practice.
Using a retrospective study of clinical histories obtained from a database at the Metabolic Research Institute, University of El Salvador School of Medicine, Buenos Aires, Argentina, as well as telephone interviews, we assessed compliance and continuance with raloxifene therapy in post-menopausal patients who had received prescriptions for raloxifene to prevent or treat osteoporosis. Patients were contacted by telephone 24 months after they had received a prescription for raloxifene. Compliance and continuance rates were calculated based on the data provided by the patients.
Data from 419 patients (mean [SD] age, 61.4 [7.4] years [range, 42-90 years]) were included in the study. At the time of the telephone interview, 225 (53.7%) were still receiving raloxifene, 105 (25.1%) had stopped treatment at their own discretion, 59 (14.1%) had not started treatment, and 30 (7.2%) had discontinued treatment as a result of advice from a physician. The reasons for not starting treatment were fear of thrombolytic events (21 patients [35.6%]); lack of interest in starting treatment (12 [20.3%]); other physician's advice (11 [18.6%]); family problems (3 [5.1%]); dissatisfaction with the prescribing physician, treatment cost, health problems unrelated to osteoporosis, and mistrust in the prescription (each, 2 [3.4%]); and advice from family/friends, fear of breast cancer, belief that raloxifene is hormonal, and that the patient was already polymedicated (each, 1 [1.7%]). Eleven of the 59 patients (18.6%) who had not started therapy were advised by a physician other than the prescribing physician not to start treatment and were excluded from the compliance analysis. Thus, the compliance analysis included 408 patients. The 2 most common reasons for discontinuing treatment at the patient's own discretion were health problems unrelated to osteoporosis (25 [23.8%]) and digestive problems not considered treatment related (16 [15.2%]). The compliance rates were 75.0%, 71.1%, 65.0%, 57.1%, and 52.0% at 3, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months, respectively. In patients who started raloxifene treatment, the continuance rates were 85.0%, 80.6%, 73.6%, 64.7%, and 58.9% at 3, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months, respectively. Sixty-two of the 135 patients who discontinued treatment did so within 3 months of receiving the prescription, accounting for 45.9% of all discontinuations.
In the present study of raloxifene compliance and continuance in clinical practice, the compliance rate appeared to be relatively high compared with those of hormone-replacement therapy (HRT) and other non-HRT treatments. Almost half of patients who discontinued treatment did so in the first 3 months.
摘要。
医生面临着患者不遵医嘱的挑战,尤其是在治疗骨质疏松等慢性无症状疾病时。
本研究旨在评估雷洛昔芬在临床实践中24个月的依从率、持续率及不良反应。
通过回顾性研究从阿根廷布宜诺斯艾利斯萨尔瓦多大学医学院代谢研究所数据库获取的临床病史,并进行电话访谈,我们评估了接受雷洛昔芬处方以预防或治疗骨质疏松的绝经后患者对雷洛昔芬治疗的依从性和持续性。在患者接受雷洛昔芬处方24个月后通过电话联系他们。根据患者提供的数据计算依从率和持续率。
419例患者(平均[标准差]年龄,61.4[7.4]岁[范围,42 - 90岁])的数据纳入研究。在电话访谈时,225例(53.7%)仍在接受雷洛昔芬治疗,105例(25.1%)自行停药,59例(14.1%)未开始治疗,30例(7.2%)因医生建议而停药。未开始治疗的原因包括担心血栓形成事件(21例[35.6%]);对开始治疗缺乏兴趣(12例[20.3%]);其他医生的建议(11例[18.6%]);家庭问题(3例[5.1%]);对开处方医生、治疗费用、与骨质疏松无关的健康问题以及对处方的不信任不满(各2例[3.4%]);以及家人/朋友的建议、担心患乳腺癌、认为雷洛昔芬是激素类药物以及患者已用药过多(各1例[1.7%])。59例未开始治疗的患者中有11例(18.6%)被开处方医生以外的其他医生建议不要开始治疗,并被排除在依从性分析之外。因此,依从性分析包括408例患者。患者自行停药的两个最常见原因是与骨质疏松无关的健康问题(25例[23.8%])和不被视为与治疗相关的消化问题(16例[15.2%])。3、6、12、18和24个月时的依从率分别为75.0%、71.1%、65.0%、57.1%和52.0%。开始雷洛昔芬治疗的患者中,3、6、12、18和24个月时的持续率分别为85.0%、80.6%、73.6%、64.7%和58.9%。135例停药患者中有62例(45.9%)在接受处方后3个月内停药。
在本项关于临床实践中雷洛昔芬依从性和持续性的研究中,与激素替代疗法(HRT)和其他非HRT治疗相比,依从率似乎相对较高。近一半停药患者在最初3个月内停药。