Christensen Deborah L, Schieve Laura A, Devine Owen, Drews-Botsch Carolyn
Division of Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities, National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, United States.
Division of Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities, National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, United States.
Res Dev Disabil. 2014 Jul;35(7):1789-801. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2014.02.003. Epub 2014 Mar 27.
Lower cognitive performance is associated with poorer health and functioning throughout the lifespan and disproportionately affects children from lower socioeconomic status (SES) populations. Previous studies reporting positive associations between child home enrichment and cognitive performance generally had a limited distribution of SES. We evaluated the associations of SES and child enrichment with cognitive performance in a population with a wide range of SES, particularly whether enrichment attenuates associations with SES. Children were sampled from a case-control study of small-for-gestational-age (SGA) conducted in a public hospital serving a low SES population (final n=198) and a private hospital serving a middle-to-high SES population (final n=253). SES (maternal education and income) and perinatal factors (SGA, maternal smoking and drinking) were obtained from maternal birth interview. Five child home enrichment factors (e.g. books in home) and preschool attendance were obtained from follow-up interview at age 4.5 years. Cognitive performance was assessed with the Differential Ability Scales (DAS), a standardized psychometric test administered at follow-up. SES and enrichment scores were created by combining individual factors. Analyses were adjusted for perinatal factors. Children from the public birth hospital had a significantly lower mean DAS general cognitive ability (GCA) score than children born at the private birth hospital (adjusted mean difference -21.4, 95% CI: -24.0, -18.7); this was substantially attenuated by adjustment for individual SES, child enrichment factors, and preschool attendance (adjusted mean difference -5.1, 95% CI: -9.5, -0.7). Individual-level SES score was associated with DAS score, beyond the general SES effect associated with hospital of birth. Adjustment for preschool attendance and home enrichment score attenuated the association between individual SES score and adjusted mean DAS-GCA among children born at both of the hospitals. The effect of being in the lower compared to the middle tertile of SES score was reduced by approximately a quarter; the effect of being in the upper compared to the middle tertile of SES score was reduced by nearly half, but this comparison was possible only for children born at the private hospital. A child's individual SES was associated with cognitive performance within advantaged and disadvantaged populations. Child enrichment was associated with better cognitive performance and attenuated the SES influence. Health care providers should reinforce guidelines for home enrichment and refer children with delays to early intervention and education, particularly children from disadvantaged populations.
较低的认知能力与一生中较差的健康状况和功能相关,并且对社会经济地位(SES)较低人群的儿童影响尤为严重。先前关于儿童家庭充实与认知能力之间存在正相关的研究,其SES分布通常有限。我们在一个SES范围广泛的人群中评估了SES和儿童充实与认知能力之间的关联,特别是充实是否会减弱与SES的关联。儿童样本来自一项针对小于胎龄儿(SGA)的病例对照研究,该研究在一家为低SES人群服务的公立医院(最终n = 198)和一家为中高SES人群服务的私立医院(最终n = 253)中进行。SES(母亲教育程度和收入)以及围产期因素(SGA、母亲吸烟和饮酒)通过母亲分娩访谈获得。五个儿童家庭充实因素(如家中藏书情况)和是否上幼儿园通过4.5岁时的随访访谈获得。认知能力通过差异能力量表(DAS)进行评估,这是一种在随访时进行的标准化心理测量测试。SES和充实得分通过合并个体因素得出。分析对围产期因素进行了调整。公立分娩医院的儿童平均DAS一般认知能力(GCA)得分显著低于私立分娩医院出生的儿童(调整后平均差异 -21.4,95% CI:-24.0,-18.7);通过对个体SES、儿童充实因素和是否上幼儿园进行调整,这一差异大幅减小(调整后平均差异 -5.1,95% CI:-9.5,-0.7)。个体层面的SES得分与DAS得分相关,超出了与出生医院相关的一般SES效应。对是否上幼儿园和家庭充实得分进行调整后,减弱了两所医院出生儿童中个体SES得分与调整后平均DAS - GCA之间的关联。与SES得分处于中间三分位数相比,处于较低三分位数的影响降低了约四分之一;与SES得分处于中间三分位数相比,处于较高三分位数的影响降低了近一半,但这种比较仅适用于私立医院出生的儿童。在优势和劣势人群中,儿童的个体SES都与认知能力相关。儿童充实与更好的认知能力相关,并减弱了SES的影响。医疗保健提供者应强化家庭充实指南,并将发育迟缓的儿童转介至早期干预和教育,尤其是来自弱势人群的儿童。