Department of Healthcare Policy and Research, School of Medicine, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia.
J Surg Oncol. 2014 Aug;110(2):207-13. doi: 10.1002/jso.23615. Epub 2014 Apr 3.
A use of polypectomy techniques by endoscopist specialty (primary care, surgery, and gastroenterology) and experience (volume), and associations with serious gastrointestinal adverse events, were examined.
A retrospective follow-up study with ambulatory surgery and hospital discharge datasets from Florida, 1999-2001, was used. Thirty-day hospitalizations due to colonic perforations and gastrointestinal bleeding were investigated for 323,585 patients.
Primary care endoscopists and surgeons used hot biopsy forceps/ablation, while gastroenterologists provided snare polypectomy or complex colonoscopy. Low-volume endoscopists were more likely to use simpler rather than complex procedures. For hot forceps/ablation and snare polypectomy, low- and medium-volume endoscopists reported higher odds of adverse events. For complex colonoscopy, higher odds of adverse events were reported for primary care endoscopists (1.74 [95% CI, 1.18-2.56]) relative to gastroenterologists.
Endoscopists regardless of specialty and experience can safely use cold biopsy forceps. For hot biopsy and snare polypectomy, low volume, but not specialty, contributed to increased odds of adverse events. For complex colonoscopy, primary care specialty, but not low volume, added to the odds of adverse events. Comparable outcomes were reported for surgeons and gastroenterologists. Cross-training and continuing medical education of primary care endoscopists in high-volume endoscopy settings are recommended for complex colonoscopy procedures.
本研究旨在探讨内镜医师专业(初级保健、外科和胃肠病学)和经验(手术量)以及息肉切除术技术的使用与严重胃肠道不良事件之间的关联。
本研究采用回顾性随访研究,使用了佛罗里达州 1999 年至 2001 年的门诊手术和住院数据集。对 323585 例患者进行了结肠穿孔和胃肠道出血导致的 30 天住院治疗调查。
初级保健内镜医师和外科医师使用热活检钳/消融术,而胃肠病学家提供圈套息肉切除术或复杂结肠镜检查。低容量内镜医师更倾向于使用简单而非复杂的程序。对于热活检钳/消融术和圈套息肉切除术,低容量和中容量内镜医师报告不良事件的可能性更高。对于复杂结肠镜检查,初级保健内镜医师(1.74[95%CI,1.18-2.56])报告不良事件的可能性高于胃肠病学家。
内镜医师无论专业和经验如何,均可安全使用冷活检钳。对于热活检和圈套息肉切除术,低容量而非专业水平与不良事件发生的可能性增加有关。对于复杂结肠镜检查,初级保健专业而非低容量与不良事件的可能性增加有关。外科医生和胃肠病学家报告的结果相当。建议对初级保健内镜医师进行高容量内镜检查环境中的交叉培训和继续医学教育,以进行复杂结肠镜检查。