Soetens Katja C M, Vandelanotte Corneel, de Vries Hein, Mummery Kerry W
a Centre for Physical Activity Studies , Institute for Health and Social Sciences Research, Central Queensland University , Rockhampton , Queensland , Australia.
J Health Commun. 2014 Dec;19(12):1377-92. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2014.894597. Epub 2014 Apr 21.
Website-delivered interventions are increasingly used to deliver physical activity interventions, yet problems with engagement and retention result in reduced effectiveness. Hence, alternative modes of online intervention delivery need to be explored. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the acceptability and effectiveness of a computer-tailored physical activity intervention delivered on the Internet in 3 delivery modes: video, text, or both. Australian adults (N = 803), recruited through e-mail, were randomized into the three delivery modes and received personal physical activity advice. Intervention content was identical across groups. Repeated measures analyses of variance were used to compare the three groups regarding acceptability, website usability, and physical activity. Participants in the video group accepted the content of the physical activity advice significantly better (F = 5.59; p < .01), and spent significantly more time on the website (F = 21.19; p < .001) compared with the text and combination groups. Total physical activity improved significantly over time in all groups (F = 3.95; p < .01). Although the combination group increased physical activity the most, few significant differences between groups were observed. Providing video-tailored feedback has advantages over the conventional text-tailored interventions; however, this study revealed few behavioral differences. More studies, examining alternative delivery modes, that can overcome the limitations of the present study, are needed.
通过网站提供的干预措施越来越多地用于实施体育活动干预,但参与度和留存率问题导致效果降低。因此,需要探索在线干预的替代模式。因此,本研究旨在评估以三种模式在互联网上提供的计算机定制体育活动干预的可接受性和有效性:视频、文本或两者结合。通过电子邮件招募的澳大利亚成年人(N = 803)被随机分为三种提供模式,并接受个人体育活动建议。各小组的干预内容相同。采用重复测量方差分析来比较三组在可接受性、网站可用性和体育活动方面的情况。与文本组和组合组相比,视频组的参与者对体育活动建议内容的接受度明显更高(F = 5.59;p <.01),在网站上花费的时间也明显更多(F = 21.19;p <.001)。所有组的总体体育活动随时间均有显著改善(F = 3.95;p <.01)。虽然组合组的体育活动增加最多,但组间观察到的显著差异很少。提供视频定制反馈比传统的文本定制干预有优势;然而,本研究揭示的行为差异很少。需要更多研究来检验能够克服本研究局限性的替代提供模式。