Sulaiman Nur Amirah, Osman Khairul, Hamzah Noor Hazfalinda, Amir Sri Pawita Albakri
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Faculty of Health Sciences, School of Diagnostic and Applied Health Sciences, Forensic Science Program, Jalan Raja Muda Abdul Aziz, 50300 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Malays J Pathol. 2014 Apr;36(1):33-9.
Deaths due to blunt force trauma to the head as a result of assault are some of the most common cases encountered by the practicing forensic pathologist. Previous studies have shown inflicting injury to the head region is one of the most effective methods of murder. The important factors that determine severity of trauma include the type of weapon used, type and site of skull fracture, intracranial haemorrhage and severity of brain injury. The aim of this study was to determine the characteristics of blunt force trauma to the skull produced by different instruments. Nine adult monkeys (Macaca fascicularis) skulls were used as models. Commonly found blunt objects comprising of Warrington hammer, hockey stick and open face helmet were used in this study. A machine calibrated force generator was used to hold the blunt object in place and to hit the skulls at forces of 12.5N and 25N. Resultant traumatic effects and fractures (linear, depressed, basilar, comminuted, and distastic) were analyzed according to type of blunt object used; surface area of contact and absolute force (N/cm(2)) delivered. Results showed that all investigated instruments were capable of producing similar injuries. The severity of trauma was not related to the surface area of contact with the blunt objects. However, only high absolute forces produced comminuted fractures. These findings were observational, as the samples were too small for statistical conclusions.
因袭击导致头部钝器伤致死是法医病理学家在实际工作中最常遇到的一些案例。先前的研究表明,对头部造成伤害是最有效的谋杀手段之一。决定创伤严重程度的重要因素包括所用武器的类型、颅骨骨折的类型和部位、颅内出血以及脑损伤的严重程度。本研究的目的是确定不同器械造成的颅骨钝器伤的特征。使用了九个成年猕猴(食蟹猴)头骨作为模型。本研究使用了常见的钝器,包括沃灵顿锤、曲棍球棒和开面头盔。使用一台经过校准的力发生器将钝器固定到位,并以12.5N和25N的力击打头骨。根据所用钝器的类型、接触表面积和施加的绝对力(N/cm²)分析由此产生的创伤效应和骨折(线性、凹陷性、基底性、粉碎性和远距离性)。结果表明,所有研究的器械都能造成类似损伤。创伤的严重程度与与钝器的接触表面积无关。然而,只有高绝对力才会导致粉碎性骨折。由于样本量太小无法得出统计学结论,这些发现只是观察性结果。