Siegenthaler Lea, Sprenger Florian D, Kneubuehl Beat P, Jackowski Christian
Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Int J Legal Med. 2018 Jan;132(1):211-217. doi: 10.1007/s00414-017-1689-0. Epub 2017 Sep 29.
Blunt force is a frequently used type of violence especially because it can be performed with basically every object of our daily lives or with bare hands or feet. The injuries and medical consequences have been widely examined, whereas the forces and especially the energies acting on impact have rarely been analyzed. The aim of the present study is to provide the impact energy and its ranges of four longish everyday items with different characteristics for male and female offenders. Additionally, the moment of inertia (MOI) for all the objects was calculated and its influence on the energy determined. A combination wrench, aluminum pipe, golf club, and spade were chosen as representatives of the four categories short, medium length with the center of mass (COM) in the middle, medium length with the COM close to the hitting point, and long and heavy. A total of 880 strikes have been performed by 11 volunteers. The results show the mean energy values of wrench, pipe, golf club, and spade for men of 51.1, 74.4, 93.5, and 166.7 J. For women, the results are 33.0, 41.0, 56.5, and 76.8 J. Knowing the energy thresholds for certain fractures and injuries, these results help to assess whether a claimed hit may have caused the fracture or injury or not.
钝器是一种常用的暴力工具,尤其是因为它基本上可以用我们日常生活中的任何物品、徒手或脚来实施。钝器造成的伤害和医学后果已得到广泛研究,而撞击时的作用力,尤其是能量,却很少被分析。本研究的目的是为男性和女性犯罪者提供四种具有不同特征的日常长条状物品的撞击能量及其范围。此外,还计算了所有物体的转动惯量(MOI),并确定了其对能量的影响。选择了组合扳手、铝管、高尔夫球杆和铲子作为四类物品的代表,分别是短的、质心(COM)在中间的中等长度、COM靠近击球点的中等长度以及长且重的。11名志愿者共进行了880次打击。结果显示,男性使用扳手、铝管、高尔夫球杆和铲子的平均能量值分别为51.1、74.4、93.5和166.7焦耳。女性的结果分别为33.0、41.0、56.5和76.8焦耳。了解某些骨折和损伤的能量阈值后,这些结果有助于评估声称的打击是否可能导致了骨折或损伤。