Lee M A, Fenster P E, Garcia Z M, Kipps J E, Huang S K
Department of Internal Medicine, Tucson Veterans Administration Medical Center, Arizona.
Can J Cardiol. 1989 Sep;5(6):295-8.
To assess the efficacy and safety of cibenzoline, 18 patients with symptomatic premature ventricular complexes (30/h or more) on baseline 48 h Holter monitors were randomized to oral cibenzoline versus placebo. The cibenzoline and placebo doses were increased from 130 to 160 mg bid after one week if premature ventricular complex (PVC) suppression was less than 75%. The double-blind placebo controlled phase (phase 1) lasted for two weeks prior to the open label long term study (phase 2). Efficacy was defined as suppression of at least 75% PVCs, 85% couplets and 90% ventricular tachycardia on follow-up 48 h Holter monitoring. At the six month mark of phase 2, patients were placed on placebo for seven days to evaluate for spontaneous resolution of PVCs. Of the seven patients on cibenzoline in phase 1, four had a positive response, one had partial control (73% suppression of PVCs) and two noted dizziness and withdrew. Of the 11 patients randomized to placebo, nine noted no change, two had a significant decrease in PVCs and one noted dizziness and withdrew. Fifteen patients were enrolled in phase 2 on open label cibenzoline at 130 to 160 mg bid. At a mean follow-up of 17 +/- 4 months (range 12 to 25), eight patients had control of symptomatic ventricular arrhythmias without adverse effects, three patients did not respond to cibenzoline, one had PVC recurrence after initial control on cibenzoline, one died of myocardial infarction without arrhythmias, one had spontaneous resolution of PVCs and one was withdrawn because of poor compliance. In conclusion, cibenzoline is effective in controlling symptomatic PVCs and is moderately well tolerated.
为评估西苯唑啉的疗效和安全性,对18例在基线48小时动态心电图监测显示有症状性室性早搏(每小时30次或更多)的患者进行随机分组,分别给予口服西苯唑啉和安慰剂。如果室性早搏(PVC)抑制率低于75%,一周后西苯唑啉和安慰剂剂量从130毫克每日两次增加至160毫克每日两次。双盲安慰剂对照阶段(第1阶段)在开放标签长期研究(第2阶段)之前持续两周。疗效定义为在随访48小时动态心电图监测中,PVC抑制至少75%、成对室性早搏抑制85%以及室性心动过速抑制90%。在第2阶段的6个月时,患者服用安慰剂7天,以评估PVC的自发缓解情况。在第1阶段服用西苯唑啉的7例患者中,4例有阳性反应,1例部分控制(PVC抑制73%),2例出现头晕并退出。在随机分配到安慰剂组的11例患者中,9例无变化,2例PVC显著减少,1例出现头晕并退出。15例患者进入第2阶段,接受130至160毫克每日两次的开放标签西苯唑啉治疗。平均随访17±4个月(范围12至25个月),8例患者控制了有症状的室性心律失常且无不良反应,3例患者对西苯唑啉无反应,1例在最初使用西苯唑啉控制后PVC复发,1例死于心肌梗死且无心律失常,1例PVC自发缓解,1例因依从性差退出。总之,西苯唑啉在控制有症状的PVC方面有效,且耐受性中等良好。