Schröder Mathis
German Institute for Economic Research (DIW), Mohrenstr. 58, 10117 Berlin, Germany.
Adv Life Course Res. 2013 Mar;18(1):5-15. doi: 10.1016/j.alcr.2012.08.001. Epub 2012 Sep 5.
In the light of the current economic crises which in many countries lead to business closures and mass lay-offs, the consequences of job loss are important on various dimensions. They have to be investigated not only in consideration of a few years, but with a long-term perspective as well, because early life course events may prove important for later life outcomes. This paper uses data from SHARELIFE to shed light on the long-term consequences of involuntary job loss on health. The paper distinguishes between two different reasons for involuntary job loss: plant closures, which in the literature are considered to be exogenous to the individual, and lay-offs, where the causal direction of health and unemployment is ambiguous. These groups are separately compared to those who never experienced a job loss. The paper uses eleven different measures of health to assess long-term health consequences of job loss, which has to have occurred at least 25 years before the current interview. As panel data cannot be employed, a large body of variables, including childhood health and socio-economic conditions, is used to control for the initial conditions. The findings suggest that individuals with an exogenous job loss suffer in the long run: men are significantly more likely to be depressed and they have more trouble knowing the current date. Women report poorer general health and more chronic conditions and are also affected in their physical health: they are more likely to be obese or overweight, and to have any limitations in their (instrumental) activities of daily living. In the comparison group of laid-off individuals, controlling for the initial conditions reduces the effects of job loss on health - proving that controlling for childhood conditions is important.
鉴于当前许多国家的经济危机导致企业倒闭和大规模裁员,失业的后果在多个层面都很重要。不仅要从几年的时间跨度来研究这些后果,还需要从长期角度进行考察,因为生命早期的经历可能对后期的生活结果具有重要影响。本文利用“共享生活”(SHARELIFE)的数据来揭示非自愿失业对健康的长期影响。本文区分了非自愿失业的两种不同原因:工厂关闭,在文献中这被视为个体外部因素;以及裁员,在这种情况下健康与失业之间的因果关系并不明确。将这两组人与从未经历过失业的人分别进行比较。本文使用了十一种不同的健康指标来评估失业的长期健康后果,这些失业必须发生在当前访谈至少25年前。由于无法使用面板数据,因此使用了大量变量,包括童年健康状况和社会经济条件,来控制初始条件。研究结果表明,因外部因素失业的个体从长期来看会受到影响:男性患抑郁症的可能性显著更高,并且在知晓当前日期方面存在更多困难。女性报告的总体健康状况较差,患有更多慢性疾病,并且身体健康也受到影响:她们更有可能肥胖或超重,并且在日常生活(工具性)活动中存在任何限制。在被裁员个体的对照组中,控制初始条件会降低失业对健康的影响——这证明控制童年状况很重要。