Chernilo Daniel
Department of Social Sciences, Loughborough University.
Br J Sociol. 2014 Jun;65(2):338-57. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.12077. Epub 2014 May 5.
This article introduces the idea of philosophical sociology as an enquiry into the relationships between implicit notions of human nature and explicit conceptualizations of social life within sociology. Philosophical sociology is also an invitation to reflect on the role of the normative in social life by looking at it sociologically and philosophically at the same: normative self-reflection is a fundamental aspect of sociology's scientific tasks because key sociological questions are, in the last instance, also philosophical ones. For the normative to emerge, we need to move away from the reductionism of hedonistic, essentialist or cynical conceptions of human nature and be able to grasp the conceptions of the good life, justice, democracy or freedom whose normative contents depend on more or less articulated conceptions of our shared humanity. The idea of philosophical sociology is then sustained on three main pillars and I use them to structure this article: (1) a revalorization of the relationships between sociology and philosophy; (2) a universalistic principle of humanity that works as a major regulative idea of sociological research, and; (3) an argument on the social (immanent) and pre-social (transcendental) sources of the normative in social life. As invitations to embrace posthuman cyborgs, non-human actants and material cultures proliferate, philosophical sociology offers the reminder that we still have to understand more fully who are the human beings that populate the social world.
本文介绍了哲学社会学的理念,即探究社会学中人性的隐含观念与社会生活的明确概念化之间的关系。哲学社会学还促使我们通过社会学和哲学的视角同时审视规范在社会生活中的作用:规范的自我反思是社会学科学任务的一个基本方面,因为关键的社会学问题最终也都是哲学问题。为了使规范得以显现,我们需要摆脱享乐主义、本质主义或犬儒主义人性观的还原论,并且能够理解美好生活、正义、民主或自由等概念,其规范内容取决于我们对共同人性或多或少清晰阐述的观念。哲学社会学的理念基于三个主要支柱,我将以此来构建本文:(1)重新评估社会学与哲学之间的关系;(2)作为社会学研究主要调节理念的普遍人性原则;(3)关于社会生活中规范的社会(内在)和前社会(先验)来源的论证。随着接纳后人类赛博格、非人类行动者和物质文化的呼声日益增多,哲学社会学提醒我们,我们仍需更全面地理解构成社会世界的人类究竟是谁。