La Rosa F, Gubbiotti C, Tozzi P
Ann Ig. 1989 Nov-Dec;1(6):1529-38.
A study utilizing cluster analysis was undertaken to evaluate the association between standardized cancer mortality rates in different Italian provinces during the period 1975-77. The cancer sites examined were: stomach, lung, colon-rectum, liver and biliary ducts, pancreas, urinary bladder, oral cavity and pharynx, oesophagus. In addition larynx and prostate were examined in males while and uterus were considered in females. The cluster analysis was carried out using the "Euclidean distance" as dissimilarity index and the UPGMA (Unweighted pair group method using arithmetic average) as a clustering method, and considering as OTUs (Operational Taxonomic Units) both cancer sites and Italian provinces. Cluster analysis applied to cancer sites showed a strong relationship, in both sexes, between the alcohol-tobacco-related neoplasms. The same association was found by other Authors in several countries of the world. A similar analysis, carried out in USA during the period 1950-67 and consistent with our results, inserted lung cancer in the same cluster. In the present study this site demonstrated different characteristics in the two sexes: in females, together with the pancreas, is clustered, at higher dissimilarity level, with oral cavity, while it remains unclustered in males. This fact is probably due to different smoking habits between the two sexes and to the importance of the alcohol-tobacco interaction. Another association, also in agreement with the results obtained by other Authors, regarded female breast and colorectal cancer on one side, and female liver and uterus cancers on the other. Gastric cancer, particularly in males, is clearly distinguished from other sites, agreeing with the concept that mortality from this site is often inversely related with that of other cancers. Cluster analysis applied to Italian provinces discriminated, in both sexes, two clusters: Northern and Southern provinces. Into these two, some clusters group provinces at high mortality from alcohol-tobacco related cancers, gastric and lung cancer. Moreover, several clusters are shown and the interpretation of the causes for those association can lead to different causal hypotheses. In conclusions, the Authors confirm that the application of this multivariate statistical method can be an efficient tool in descriptive epidemiology. The results obtained in this study, while partially agreeing with the international literature, constitute a starting point for formulating new hypotheses which take into account the relationships and interactions between several risk factors.
一项利用聚类分析的研究旨在评估1975 - 1977年期间意大利不同省份标准化癌症死亡率之间的关联。所检查的癌症部位包括:胃、肺、结肠 - 直肠、肝和胆管、胰腺、膀胱、口腔和咽部、食管。此外,对男性检查了喉和前列腺,对女性检查了子宫。聚类分析使用“欧氏距离”作为相异指数,采用UPGMA(非加权组平均法)作为聚类方法,并将癌症部位和意大利省份都视为OTU(操作分类单元)。对癌症部位进行的聚类分析表明,在两性中,与酒精 - 烟草相关的肿瘤之间存在很强的关系。其他作者在世界上几个国家也发现了同样的关联。美国在1950 - 1967年期间进行的一项类似分析与我们的结果一致,将肺癌归入同一聚类。在本研究中,该部位在两性中表现出不同特征:在女性中,它与胰腺一起,以较高的相异水平,与口腔聚类,而在男性中它未聚类。这一事实可能归因于两性不同的吸烟习惯以及酒精 - 烟草相互作用的重要性。另一种关联也与其他作者获得的结果一致,一方面涉及女性乳腺癌和结直肠癌,另一方面涉及女性肝癌和子宫癌。胃癌,尤其是男性胃癌,明显与其他部位区分开来,这与该部位的死亡率通常与其他癌症死亡率呈负相关的概念相符。对意大利省份进行的聚类分析在两性中都区分出两个聚类:北部省份和南部省份。在这两个聚类中,一些聚类将酒精 - 烟草相关癌症、胃癌和肺癌死亡率高的省份归为一组。此外,还显示了几个聚类,对这些关联原因的解释可能会导致不同的因果假设。总之,作者证实这种多元统计方法的应用可以成为描述性流行病学中的一种有效工具。本研究获得的结果虽然部分与国际文献一致,但构成了制定新假设的起点,这些假设考虑了几个风险因素之间的关系和相互作用。