Sumner Steven A, Pallangyo Anthony J, Reddy Elizabeth A, Maro Venance, Pence Brian W, Lynch Catherine, Turner Elizabeth L, Egger Joseph R, Thielman Nathan M
Duke University, Hubert Yeargan Center for Global Health, Durham, United States.
Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, Orthopaedics Department, Moshi, Tanzania.
Injury. 2014 Nov;45(11):1681-6. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2014.04.034. Epub 2014 Apr 29.
Deaths due to road traffic injuries, particularly motorcycle crashes, have increased rapidly in many African nations and context-specific strategies to improve preventative behaviours are needed. Although adhering to conspicuity measures by wearing reflective safety vests is a highly effective crash prevention strategy and mandated by law among motorcycle-taxi drivers in some African countries, actual use is currently low. We aimed to test whether eliminating cost-barriers through the provision of free reflective, fluorescent motorcycle safety vests would lead to increased utilisation among a high-risk population of motorcycle-taxi drivers in Tanzania.
A cluster randomised controlled trial was conducted among 180 motorcycle-taxi drivers. Participants randomised to the intervention arm (90) received free, reflective, fluorescent vests; participants randomised to the control arm (90) did not receive free vests. Participants' use of reflective vests was then observed on city streets over a three month period and differential uptake was estimated using mixed-effects logistic regression.
Baseline use of reflective vests was 3.3% in both arms. Seventy-nine drivers in the intervention arm and 82 drivers in the control arm were observed during follow-up. The average proportion of observations during which motorcycle drivers were using a reflective vest was 9.5% in the intervention arm, compared to 2.0% in the control arm (odds ratio: 5.5, 95% confidence interval: 1.1-26.9, p-value: 0.04).
Although distribution of free reflective vests led to a statistically significant increase in vest usage, the absolute increase was modest. Additional strategies beyond removing economic barriers are important to augment adherence to road safety behaviours for injury prevention.
在许多非洲国家,因道路交通伤害,尤其是摩托车事故导致的死亡人数迅速增加,因此需要制定针对具体情况的策略来改善预防行为。虽然穿着反光安全背心以遵守醒目措施是一种非常有效的预防碰撞策略,并且在一些非洲国家已被法律强制要求摩托车出租车司机执行,但目前实际使用率较低。我们旨在测试通过提供免费的反光荧光摩托车安全背心来消除成本障碍是否会导致坦桑尼亚高风险摩托车出租车司机群体中背心使用率的提高。
对180名摩托车出租车司机进行了一项整群随机对照试验。随机分配到干预组(90名)的参与者获得免费的反光荧光背心;随机分配到对照组(90名)的参与者未获得免费背心。然后在三个月的时间内在城市街道上观察参与者对反光背心的使用情况,并使用混合效应逻辑回归估计差异接受率。
两组中反光背心的基线使用率均为3.3%。在随访期间,干预组观察到79名司机,对照组观察到82名司机。干预组中摩托车司机使用反光背心的观察平均比例为9.5%,而对照组为2.0%(优势比:5.5,95%置信区间:1.1 - 26.9,p值:0.04)。
虽然免费发放反光背心导致背心使用率在统计学上有显著提高,但绝对增幅不大。除了消除经济障碍之外,还需要其他策略来增强对道路安全行为的遵守,以预防伤害。