Chin Christopher J, Roth Kathryn, Rotenberg Brian W, Fung Kevin
Department of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Laryngoscope. 2014 Oct;124(10):2275-80. doi: 10.1002/lary.24754. Epub 2014 Jun 10.
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: A 1-day intensive course (bootcamp) was developed, to teach junior otolaryngology-head and neck surgery (OTO-HNS) residents emergency procedural skills, clinical reasoning, and communication skills. This learning paradigm utilized a number of novel task trainers, panel discussions, and emergency simulations. The study objective was to assess the educational value of this bootcamp.
Prospective cohort survey.
Residents were recruited from regional teaching centers within a 2000-km radius of the simulation center. Preceptors fluent in English and in French were in attendance. Pre-bootcamp outcome measures included the Kolb Learning Style Inventory and a self-administered survey measuring confidence levels in performing specific OTO-HNS tasks. Post-bootcamp outcome measures included a survey evaluating the bootcamp experience and a structured follow-up telephone interview.
Twenty-eight residents participated in the bootcamp from across the United States and Canada. When asked if they felt that "overall, the educational day was an effective learning process," the average score was 4.75/5.0. The vast majority of participants (92.9%) felt they would recommend the bootcamp to a future junior resident. Kolb learning styles that prefer active experimentation (acting, initiating, and deciding) were more common than those that utilize reflective observation (imagining, analyzing, reflecting), which favors a hands-on model of learning.
This first Canadian OTO-HNS bootcamp demonstrated the feasibility and effectiveness of conducting a centralized bootcamp for regional training centers spanning multiple states/provinces and languages. Future bootcamps will be held annually and will ideally continue the natural evolution of surgical, hands-on training.
目的/假设:开发了一门为期1天的强化课程(集训营),用于教授初级耳鼻咽喉-头颈外科(OTO-HNS)住院医师应急操作技能、临床推理和沟通技巧。这种学习模式采用了多种新型任务训练器、小组讨论和应急模拟。研究目的是评估该集训营的教育价值。
前瞻性队列调查。
从模拟中心半径2000公里范围内的地区教学中心招募住院医师。有精通英语和法语的带教老师在场。集训营前的结果测量包括科尔布学习风格量表和一项自我管理的调查,该调查测量执行特定OTO-HNS任务时的信心水平。集训营后的结果测量包括一项评估集训营体验的调查和一次结构化的随访电话访谈。
来自美国和加拿大各地的28名住院医师参加了集训营。当被问及是否认为“总体而言,这一天的教育活动是一个有效的学习过程”时,平均得分为4.75/5.0。绝大多数参与者(92.9%)认为他们会向未来的初级住院医师推荐该集训营。偏好主动实验(行动、发起和决策)而非反思观察(想象、分析、反思)的科尔布学习风格更为常见,反思观察更倾向于实践操作的学习模式。
首个加拿大OTO-HNS集训营证明了为跨越多个州/省和多种语言的地区培训中心开展集中式集训营的可行性和有效性。未来的集训营将每年举办,理想情况下将继续外科实践操作培训的自然发展。