Partosch Falko, Mielke Hans, Stahlmann Ralf, Kleuser Burkhard, Barlow Susan, Gundert-Remy Ursula
Institute for Clinical Pharmacology and Toxicology, Charité - Universitätsmedizin, Berlin, Germany.
Arch Toxicol. 2015 Jun;89(6):941-8. doi: 10.1007/s00204-014-1287-6. Epub 2014 Jun 12.
The TTC concept uses toxicological data from animal testing to derive generic human exposure threshold values (TTC values), below which the risk of adverse effects on human health is considered to be low. It uses distributions of no-observed-adverse-effect levels (NOAELs) for substances. The 5th percentile value is divided by an uncertainty factor (100) to give a TTC value. As the toxicological data underpinning the TTC concept are from tests with oral exposure, the exposure is to be understood as an external oral exposure. For risk assessment of substances with a low absorption (by the oral route, or through skin), the internal exposure is more relevant than the external exposure. European legislation allows that tests might not be necessary for substances with negligible absorption with low internal exposure. The aim of this work is to derive internal TTC values to allow the TTC concept to be applied to situations of low internal exposure. The external NOAEL of each chemical of three databases (Munro, ELINCS, Food Contact Materials) was multiplied by the bioavailability of the individual chemical. Oral bioavailability was predicted using an in silico prediction tool (ACD Percepta). After applying a reduced uncertainty factor of 25, we derived internal TTC values. For Cramer class I, the internal TTC values are 6.9 μg/kg bw/d (90 % confidence interval: 3.8-11.5 mg/kg bw/d); for Cramer class II/III 0.1 μg/kg bw/d (90 % confidence interval: 0.08-0.14 μg/kg bw/d).
TTC概念利用动物试验的毒理学数据得出通用的人体暴露阈值(TTC值),低于该值时,对人体健康产生不良影响的风险被认为较低。它使用物质的未观察到不良反应水平(NOAELs)分布。将第5百分位数除以一个不确定性系数(100)得出TTC值。由于支撑TTC概念的毒理学数据来自口服暴露试验,所以该暴露应理解为外部口服暴露。对于吸收低的物质(经口服途径或通过皮肤)进行风险评估时,内部暴露比外部暴露更具相关性。欧洲法规允许对于吸收可忽略且内部暴露低的物质可能无需进行试验。这项工作的目的是得出内部TTC值,以便将TTC概念应用于低内部暴露情况。将三个数据库(Munro、ELINCS、食品接触材料)中每种化学品的外部NOAEL乘以该化学品的生物利用度。使用计算机预测工具(ACD Percepta)预测口服生物利用度。应用25的降低不确定性系数后,我们得出了内部TTC值。对于克莱默I类,内部TTC值为6.9微克/千克体重/天(90%置信区间:3.8 - 11.5毫克/千克体重/天);对于克莱默II/III类为0.1微克/千克体重/天(90%置信区间:0.08 - 0.14微克/千克体重/天)。