Filiou Michaela D, Arefin Ahmed Shamsul, Moscato Pablo, Graeber Manuel B
Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, Kraepelinstraße 2, 80804, Munich, Germany.
Neurogenetics. 2014 Aug;15(3):201-12. doi: 10.1007/s10048-014-0409-x. Epub 2014 Jun 15.
'Neuroinflammation' has become a widely applied term in the basic and clinical neurosciences but there is no generally accepted neuropathological tissue correlate. Inflammation, which is characterized by the presence of perivascular infiltrates of cells of the adaptive immune system, is indeed seen in the central nervous system (CNS) under certain conditions. Authors who refer to microglial activation as neuroinflammation confuse this issue because autoimmune neuroinflammation serves as a synonym for multiple sclerosis, the prototypical inflammatory disease of the CNS. We have asked the question whether a data-driven, unbiased in silico approach may help to clarify the nomenclatorial confusion. Specifically, we have examined whether unsupervised analysis of microarray data obtained from human cerebral cortex of Alzheimer's, Parkinson's and schizophrenia patients would reveal a degree of relatedness between these diseases and recognized inflammatory conditions including multiple sclerosis. Our results using two different data analysis methods provide strong evidence against this hypothesis demonstrating that very different sets of genes are involved. Consequently, the designations inflammation and neuroinflammation are not interchangeable. They represent different categories not only at the histophenotypic but also at the transcriptomic level. Therefore, non-autoimmune neuroinflammation remains a term in need of definition.
“神经炎症”已成为基础神经科学和临床神经科学中广泛应用的术语,但目前尚无普遍认可的神经病理学组织关联。在某些情况下,中枢神经系统(CNS)中确实会出现以适应性免疫系统细胞的血管周围浸润为特征的炎症。将小胶质细胞激活称为神经炎症的作者混淆了这个问题,因为自身免疫性神经炎症是中枢神经系统典型炎症性疾病——多发性硬化症的同义词。我们提出了一个问题,即数据驱动的、无偏倚的计算机方法是否有助于澄清命名上的混淆。具体而言,我们研究了对从阿尔茨海默病、帕金森病和精神分裂症患者的人类大脑皮层获得的微阵列数据进行无监督分析,是否会揭示这些疾病与包括多发性硬化症在内的公认炎症性疾病之间的某种关联程度。我们使用两种不同数据分析方法得到的结果有力地反驳了这一假设,表明涉及的基因集差异很大。因此,“炎症”和“神经炎症”这两个术语不可互换。它们不仅在组织表型水平,而且在转录组水平都代表不同的类别。因此,非自身免疫性神经炎症仍然是一个需要定义的术语。