Alhamud A, Taylor Paul A, Laughton Barbara, van der Kouwe André J W, Meintjes Ernesta M
MRC/UCT Medical Imaging Research Unit, Department of Human Biology, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, Observatory, Cape Town, South Africa.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2015 May;41(5):1353-64. doi: 10.1002/jmri.24678. Epub 2014 Jun 17.
To evaluate the patterns of head motion in scans of young children and to examine the influence of corrective techniques, both qualitatively and quantitatively. We investigate changes that both retrospective (with and without diffusion table reorientation) and prospective (implemented with a short navigator sequence) motion correction induce in the resulting diffusion tensor measures.
Eighteen pediatric subjects (aged 5-6 years) were scanned using 1) a twice-refocused, 2D diffusion pulse sequence, 2) a prospectively motion-corrected, navigated diffusion sequence with reacquisition of a maximum of five corrupted diffusion volumes, and 3) a T1 -weighted structural image. Mean fractional anisotropy (FA) values in white and gray matter regions, as well as tractography in the brainstem and projection fibers, were evaluated to assess differences arising from retrospective (via FLIRT in FSL) and prospective motion correction. In addition to human scans, a stationary phantom was also used for further evaluation.
In several white and gray matter regions retrospective correction led to significantly (P < 0.05) reduced FA means and altered distributions compared to the navigated sequence. Spurious tractographic changes in the retrospectively corrected data were also observed in subject data, as well as in phantom and simulated data.
Due to the heterogeneity of brain structures and the comparatively low resolution (∼2 mm) of diffusion data using 2D single shot sequencing, retrospective motion correction is susceptible to distortion from partial voluming. These changes often negatively bias diffusion tensor imaging parameters. Prospective motion correction was shown to produce smaller changes.
评估幼儿扫描中头部运动模式,并从定性和定量两方面检查校正技术的影响。我们研究回顾性(有和没有扩散表重新定向)和前瞻性(通过短导航序列实施)运动校正对所得扩散张量测量值的影响。
对18名儿科受试者(5 - 6岁)进行扫描,使用1)二次重聚焦的二维扩散脉冲序列,2)前瞻性运动校正的导航扩散序列,最多重新采集5个损坏的扩散容积,以及3)T1加权结构图像。评估白质和灰质区域的平均分数各向异性(FA)值,以及脑干和投射纤维的纤维束成像,以评估回顾性(通过FSL中的FLIRT)和前瞻性运动校正产生的差异。除了人体扫描外,还使用固定体模进行进一步评估。
在几个白质和灰质区域,与导航序列相比,回顾性校正导致FA平均值显著降低(P < 0.05)且分布改变。在受试者数据以及体模和模拟数据中,也观察到回顾性校正数据中出现的虚假纤维束成像变化。
由于脑结构的异质性以及使用二维单次激发测序的扩散数据分辨率相对较低(约2毫米),回顾性运动校正容易受到部分容积效应导致的失真影响。这些变化常常对扩散张量成像参数产生负偏差。前瞻性运动校正显示产生的变化较小。