Seo Yoonjeong, Lee In-Seon, Jung Won-Mo, Ryu Ho-Sun, Lim Jinwoong, Ryu Yeon-Hee, Kang Jung-Won, Chae Younbyoung
Acupuncture and Meridian Science Research Center, College of Korean Medicine, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Korea College of Korean Medicine, Semyung University, Jecheon, Korea.
Acupuncture and Meridian Science Research Center, College of Korean Medicine, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Korea.
Acupunct Med. 2014 Oct;32(5):394-9. doi: 10.1136/acupmed-2014-010585. Epub 2014 Jun 17.
In clinical practice, acupuncture manipulation is highly individualised for each practitioner. Before we establish a standard for acupuncture manipulation, it is important to understand completely the manifestations of acupuncture manipulation in the actual clinic. To examine motion patterns during acupuncture manipulation, we generated a fitted model of practitioners' motion patterns and evaluated their consistencies in acupuncture manipulation.
Using a motion sensor, we obtained real-time motion data from eight experienced practitioners while they conducted acupuncture manipulation using their own techniques. We calculated the average amplitude and duration of a sampled motion unit for each practitioner and, after normalisation, we generated a true regression curve of motion patterns for each practitioner using a generalised additive mixed modelling (GAMM).
We observed significant differences in rotation amplitude and duration in motion samples among practitioners. GAMM showed marked variations in average regression curves of motion patterns among practitioners but there was strong consistency in motion parameters for individual practitioners. The fitted regression model showed that the true regression curve accounted for an average of 50.2% of variance in the motion pattern for each practitioner.
Our findings suggest that there is great inter-individual variability between practitioners, but remarkable intra-individual consistency within each practitioner.
在临床实践中,针刺手法因从业者而异,具有高度个体化特点。在建立针刺手法标准之前,全面了解针刺手法在实际临床中的表现非常重要。为了研究针刺手法过程中的运动模式,我们生成了从业者运动模式的拟合模型,并评估了他们在针刺手法中的一致性。
我们使用运动传感器,在八名经验丰富的从业者运用各自技术进行针刺手法操作时,获取他们的实时运动数据。我们计算了每位从业者采样运动单元的平均幅度和持续时间,并在归一化后,使用广义相加混合模型(GAMM)为每位从业者生成运动模式的真实回归曲线。
我们观察到从业者之间运动样本的旋转幅度和持续时间存在显著差异。GAMM显示,从业者之间运动模式的平均回归曲线存在明显差异,但个体从业者的运动参数具有很强的一致性。拟合回归模型表明,真实回归曲线平均占每位从业者运动模式方差的50.2%。
我们的研究结果表明,从业者之间存在很大的个体差异,但每位从业者内部具有显著的个体内一致性。