Kim Jibum, Smith Tom W, Kang Jeong-han
Department of Sociology, Sungkyunkwan University, 25-2 Sungkyunkwan-ro, Jongno-gu, Faculty Hall, #513, Seoul, 110-745, Korea.
GSS, NORC at the University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
J Relig Health. 2015 Dec;54(6):2052-72. doi: 10.1007/s10943-014-9902-7.
Very few studies have examined the effects of both religious affiliation and religiosity on mortality at the same time, and studies employing multiple dimensions of religiosity other than religious attendance are rare. Using the newly created General Social Survey-National Death Index data, our report contributes to the religion and mortality literature by examining religious affiliation and religiosity at the same time. Compared to Mainline Protestants, Catholics, Jews, and other religious groups have lower risk of death, but Black Protestants, Evangelical Protestants, and even those with no religious affiliation are not different from Mainline Protestants. While our study is consistent with previous findings that religious attendance leads to a reduction in mortality, we did not find other religious measures, such as strength of religious affiliation, frequency of praying, belief in an afterlife, and belief in God to be associated with mortality. We also find interaction effects between religious affiliation and attendance. The lowest mortality of Jews and other religious groups is more apparent for those with lower religious attendance. Thus, our result may emphasize the need for other research to focus on the effects of religious group and religious attendance on mortality at the same time.
很少有研究同时考察宗教归属和宗教虔诚度对死亡率的影响,而且除了宗教礼拜之外,采用宗教虔诚度多个维度的研究也很罕见。利用新创建的综合社会调查-国家死亡指数数据,我们的报告通过同时考察宗教归属和宗教虔诚度,为宗教与死亡率的文献做出了贡献。与主流新教徒相比,天主教徒、犹太人和其他宗教群体的死亡风险较低,但黑人新教徒、福音派新教徒,甚至那些无宗教归属的人与主流新教徒并无差异。虽然我们的研究与之前关于宗教礼拜会降低死亡率的发现一致,但我们并未发现其他宗教指标,如宗教归属强度、祈祷频率、对来世的信仰以及对上帝的信仰与死亡率有关。我们还发现宗教归属和礼拜之间存在交互作用。对于宗教礼拜较少的人来说,犹太人和其他宗教群体的最低死亡率更为明显。因此,我们的结果可能强调其他研究需要同时关注宗教群体和宗教礼拜对死亡率的影响。