Stulík J, Adámek S, Barna M, Kaspříková N, Polanecký O, Kryl J
Spondylochirurgické oddělení FN Motol, Praha.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2014;81(3):203-11.
The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate clinical and radiographic results in the patients who underwent L5-S1 fixation using the technique of percutaneous lumbar interbody fusion (AxiaLIF).
The study comprised 23 patients, 11 women and 12 men, who ranged from age of 21 to 63 years, with an average of 48.2 years. In all patients surgical posterior stabilisation involving the L5-S1 segment had previously been done. The initial indications for surgery were L5-S1 spondylolisthesis in 20 and L5-S1 spondylosis and stenosis in three patients.
The AxiaLIF technique for L5-S1 fixation was indicated in overweight patients and in those after repeated abdominal or retroperitoneal surgery. A suitable position and shape of the sacrum or lumbosacral junction was another criterion. The patients were evaluated between 26 and 56 months (average, 40.4 months) after primary surgery and, on the basis of CT and radiographic findings, bone union and lumbosacral junction stability were assessed. The clinical outcome was investigated using the ODI and VAS systems and the results were statistically analysed by the Wilcoxon test for paired samples with statistical significance set at a level of 0.05.
The average VAS value was 6.6 before surgery and, after surgery, 5.2 at three months, 4.2 at six months, 3.1 at one year, 2.9 at two years and 2.1 at three years (n=18). At two post-operative years, improvement in the VAS value by 56.1% was recorded. The average pre-operative ODI value was 25.1; the post-operative values were 17.0 at six months, 12.3 at one year, 10.6 at two years and 8.2 at three years (n=18). At two years after surgery the ODI value improved by 57.8%. To the question concerning their willingness to undergo, with acquired experience, surgery for the same diagnosis, 21 patients (91.3%) gave an affirmative answer. Neither screw breakage nor neurovascular damage or rectal injury was found. CT scans showed complete interbody bone fusion in 22 of the 23 patients (95.6%), In one patient the finding was not clear. Also, posterolateral fusion was achieved in all but one patients (95.6%). A stable L5-S1 segment was found in all patients at all follow-up intervals. The improvement in both VAS and ODI values was statistically significant.
In addition to indications usual in degenerative disc disease, overweight patients, those who had repeated trans- or retroperitoneal surgery in the L5-S1 region or who underwent long posterior fixation to stabilise the caudal margin of instrumentation are indicated for the AxiaLIF procedure. The clinical results of our study are in agreement with the conclusions of other studies and are similar to the outcomes of surgery using other types of fusion or dynamic stabilisation for this diagnosis. The high rate of fusion in our group is affected by use of a rigid transpedicular fixator together with posterolateral arthrodesis. On the other hand, no negative effects of only synthetic bone applied to interbody space were recorded.
The percutaneous axial pre-sacral approach to the L5-S1 interbody space with application of a double-treaded screw is another option for the management of this much strained segment. The technique is useful particularly when contraindications for conventional surgical procedures are present in patients with anatomical anomalies, in overweight patients or in those who have had repeated surgery in the region. Clinical outcomes and the success rate for L5-S1 bone fusion are comparable with conventional techniques. Complications are rare but their treatment is difficult.
本前瞻性研究的目的是评估采用经皮腰椎椎间融合术(AxiaLIF)技术进行L5-S1固定的患者的临床和影像学结果。
本研究纳入23例患者,其中女性11例,男性12例,年龄在21至63岁之间,平均年龄48.2岁。所有患者此前均已进行过涉及L5-S1节段的手术后路稳定术。手术的初始指征为20例L5-S1椎体滑脱,3例L5-S1椎体骨质增生和椎管狭窄。
AxiaLIF技术用于L5-S1固定适用于超重患者以及接受过反复腹部或腹膜后手术的患者。骶骨或腰骶关节的合适位置和形态是另一个标准。在初次手术后26至56个月(平均40.4个月)对患者进行评估,并根据CT和影像学检查结果评估骨融合和腰骶关节稳定性。使用ODI和VAS系统调查临床结果,并通过配对样本的Wilcoxon检验进行统计分析,设定统计学显著性水平为0.05。
术前平均VAS值为6.6,术后3个月为5.2,6个月为4.2,1年为3.1,2年为2.9,3年为2.1(n = 18)。术后2年,VAS值改善了56.1%。术前平均ODI值为25.1;术后6个月为17.0,1年为12.3,2年为10.6,3年为8.2(n = 18)。术后2年ODI值改善了57.8%。对于关于他们在获得经验后是否愿意因相同诊断接受手术的问题,21例患者(91.3%)给出了肯定回答。未发现螺钉断裂、神经血管损伤或直肠损伤。CT扫描显示23例患者中有22例(95.6%)椎间骨完全融合,1例患者结果不明确。此外,除1例患者外所有患者均实现了后外侧融合(95.6%)。在所有随访期间所有患者均发现L5-S1节段稳定。VAS和ODI值的改善均具有统计学显著性。
除了退行性椎间盘疾病常见指征外,超重患者、在L5-S1区域接受过反复经腹或腹膜后手术的患者或接受过长后路固定以稳定器械尾端的患者适用于AxiaLIF手术。我们研究的临床结果与其他研究的结论一致,并且与使用其他类型融合或动态稳定化进行该诊断的手术结果相似。我们组的高融合率受使用刚性椎弓根固定器联合后外侧关节融合术的影响。另一方面,未记录仅应用于椎间间隙的合成骨的负面影响。
经皮轴向骶前入路至L5-S1椎间间隙并应用双螺纹螺钉是处理这个负荷较大节段的另一种选择。该技术特别适用于存在解剖异常的患者、超重患者或在该区域接受过反复手术的患者中存在传统手术禁忌证的情况。L5-S1骨融合的临床结果和成功率与传统技术相当。并发症罕见但治疗困难。