Rouquette Olivier, Bommelaer Gilles, Abergel Armando, Poincloux Laurent
Olivier Rouquette, Gilles Bommelaer, Armando Abergel, Laurent Poincloux, Digestive Endoscopy Unit, CHU Estaing, 63000 Clermont-Ferrand, France.
World J Gastroenterol. 2014 Jun 28;20(24):7760-6. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i24.7760.
Endoscopic sphincterotomy (ES) is the standard therapy in common bile duct (CBD) stones extraction. Large stones (≥ 12 mm) or multiple stones extraction may be challenging after ES alone. Endoscopic sphincterotomy followed by large balloon dilation (ESLBD) has been described as an alternative to ES in these indications. Efficacy, safety, cost-effectiveness and technical aspects of the procedure have been here reviewed. PubMed and Google Scholar search resulted in forty-one articles dealing with CBD stone extraction with 12 mm or more dilation balloons after ES. ESLBD is at least as effective as ES, and reduces the need for additional mechanical lithotripsy. Adverse events rates are not statistically different after ESLBD compared to ES for pancreatitis, bleeding and perforation. However, particular attention should be paid in patients with CBD strictures, which is identified as a risk factor of perforation. ESLBD is slightly cost-effective compared to ES. A small sphincterotomy is usually performed, and may reduce bleeding rates compared to full sphincterotomy. Dilation is performed with 12-20 mm enteral balloons. Optimal inflation time is yet to be determined. The procedure can be performed safely even in patients with peri-ampullary diverticula and surgically altered anatomy. ESLBD is effective and safe in the removal of large CBD stones, however, small sphincterotomy might be preferred and CBD strictures should be considered as a relative contraindication.
内镜括约肌切开术(ES)是胆总管(CBD)结石取出的标准治疗方法。仅行ES后取出大结石(≥12mm)或多个结石可能具有挑战性。内镜括约肌切开术联合大球囊扩张术(ESLBD)已被描述为这些适应证中ES的替代方法。本文回顾了该手术的疗效、安全性、成本效益和技术方面。通过PubMed和谷歌学术搜索,得到41篇关于ES后使用直径12mm或更大的扩张球囊进行CBD结石取出的文章。ESLBD至少与ES一样有效,并减少了额外机械碎石的需求。与ES相比,ESLBD后胰腺炎、出血和穿孔的不良事件发生率在统计学上无差异。然而,对于CBD狭窄患者应特别注意,CBD狭窄被确定为穿孔的危险因素。与ES相比,ESLBD的成本效益略高。通常进行小切口括约肌切开术,与完全括约肌切开术相比,可能会降低出血率。使用12 - 20mm的肠道球囊进行扩张。最佳充盈时间尚未确定。即使在患有壶腹周围憩室和解剖结构已手术改变的患者中,该手术也能安全进行。ESLBD在取出大的CBD结石方面有效且安全,然而,可能更倾向于小切口括约肌切开术,并且CBD狭窄应被视为相对禁忌证。