Fessler Daniel M T, Holbrook Colin, Gervais Matthew M
Department of Anthropology and Center for Behavior, Evolution, and Culture, University of California, 341 Haines Hall, Los Angeles, CA, 90095-1553, USA,
Hum Nat. 2014 Sep;25(3):393-409. doi: 10.1007/s12110-014-9205-4.
Across taxa, strength and size are elementary determinants of relative fighting capacity; in species with complex behavioral repertoires, numerous additional factors also contribute. When many factors must be considered simultaneously, decision-making in agonistic contexts can be facilitated through the use of a summary representation. Size and strength may constitute the dimensions used to form such a representation, such that tactical advantages or liabilities influence the conceptualized size and muscularity of an antagonist. If so, and given the continued importance of physical strength in human male-male conflicts, a man's own strength will influence his conceptualization of the absolute size and strength of an opponent. In the research reported here, male participants' chest compression strength was compared with their estimates of the size and muscularity of an unfamiliar potential antagonist, presented either as a supporter of a rival sports team (Study 1, conducted in urban California, and Study 2, conducted in rural Fiji) or as a man armed with a handgun (Study 3, conducted in rural Fiji). Consistent with predictions, composite measures of male participants' estimates of the size/strength of a potential antagonist were inversely correlated with the participant's own strength. Therefore, consonant with a history wherein violent intrasexual selection has acted on human males, a man's own physical strength influences his representations of potential antagonists.
在不同物种中,力量和体型是相对战斗能力的基本决定因素;在具有复杂行为模式的物种中,还有许多其他因素也起作用。当必须同时考虑多个因素时,通过使用一种概括性表征可以促进在争斗情境中的决策。体型和力量可能构成用于形成这种表征的维度,这样战术优势或劣势会影响对对手概念化的体型和肌肉发达程度。如果是这样,并且考虑到体力在人类男性之间冲突中持续具有的重要性,一个男人自身的力量会影响他对对手绝对体型和力量的概念化。在本文所报告的研究中,将男性参与者的胸部按压力量与其对一个不熟悉的潜在对手的体型和肌肉发达程度的估计进行了比较,该对手要么表现为敌对运动队的支持者(研究1,在加利福尼亚城市进行,以及研究2,在斐济农村进行),要么表现为手持手枪的男子(研究3,在斐济农村进行)。与预测一致,男性参与者对潜在对手体型/力量估计的综合测量值与参与者自身的力量呈负相关。因此,与暴力同性选择作用于人类男性的历史相一致,一个男人自身的体力会影响他对潜在对手的表征。