García-Camba Pablo, Varela Margarita, Requena Luis
*Unit of Orthodontics, Fundación Jiménez Díaz, Universidad Autónoma, Madrid, Spain; and †Department of Dermatology, Fundación Jiménez Díaz, Universidad Autónoma, Madrid, Spain.
Am J Dermatopathol. 2014 Dec;36(12):952-8. doi: 10.1097/DAD.0000000000000107.
Oral pathology is an interdisciplinary field of unclear boundaries. Only a few studies have been previously published comparing the diagnostic capacity among different specialists taking care of the disorders involving oral mucosa and perioral skin. The goal of this study was to assess the capacity for diagnosing dermatologic conditions involving the oral mucosa and perioral skin in children and adults among orthodontists, dermatologists, and primary care physicians. Samples of orthodontists (n = 118), dermatologists (n = 100), pediatricians (n = 75), and family doctors (n = 68) were selected for the study. Two tests of 30 color clinical photographs each were prepared, one containing oral lesions in children and other one in adults. Statistical and comparative analyses of correct and incorrect answers were performed in each group and subgroup of participants. Dermatologists were clearly better trained than other specialists in oral and perioral pathology. This advantage over their counterparts in other specialties was seen in both residents and board-certified dermatologists. Though by small margin, orthodontists showed better performance than pediatricians and family doctors. Dermatologists showed higher capacity to achieve the right diagnosis in common oral and perioral disorders than orthodontists, pediatricians, and family doctors.
口腔病理学是一个边界不明确的跨学科领域。此前仅有少数研究比较了不同专科医生对涉及口腔黏膜和口周皮肤疾病的诊断能力。本研究的目的是评估正畸医生、皮肤科医生和初级保健医生对儿童和成人涉及口腔黏膜和口周皮肤的皮肤病的诊断能力。选取了正畸医生(n = 118)、皮肤科医生(n = 100)、儿科医生(n = 75)和家庭医生(n = 68)作为研究样本。准备了两项测试,每项测试有30张彩色临床照片,一组包含儿童口腔病变,另一组包含成人口腔病变。对每个参与者组和子组的正确和错误答案进行了统计和比较分析。皮肤科医生在口腔和口周病理学方面的培训明显优于其他专科医生。无论是住院医生还是获得委员会认证的皮肤科医生,与其他专科的同行相比都具有这一优势。虽然优势不大,但正畸医生的表现优于儿科医生和家庭医生。在常见的口腔和口周疾病中,皮肤科医生做出正确诊断的能力高于正畸医生、儿科医生和家庭医生。