Campbell Lauren J, Li Qinghua, Li Yue
Department of Public Health Sciences, Division of Health Policy and Outcomes Research, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY.
Department of Public Health Sciences, Division of Health Policy and Outcomes Research, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY.
J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2014 Oct;15(10):768-72. doi: 10.1016/j.jamda.2014.06.005. Epub 2014 Jul 20.
Nursing home (NH) employee influenza vaccination is associated with reductions in morbidity and mortality among residents. Little is known regarding associations between NH characteristics and employee influenza vaccination rates (EVRs). This study identifies NH characteristics that may be associated with EVRs.
Data on employee vaccination rates and programs were gathered from the Office for Oregon Health Policy and Research reports for 3 influenza seasons from 2009 to 2012 and merged with Online Survey, Certification, and Reporting files, from which facility characteristics were obtained. Market controls were obtained from the 2010 Area Health Resource File. Multivariate linear and logistic regression were used to model relationships between facility characteristics and EVR per facility per year, whether formal education for employees was conducted, and whether 2010, 2015, and 2020 Healthy People targets were met.
Oregon nursing homes from 2009 to 2012.
NHs reporting sufficient data to calculate an EVR were included. Based on information obtained from 2009-2010, 2010-2011, and 2011-2012 surveys, EVRs were calculated for 113/140, 129/141, and 137/140 (81%, 91%, and 98% of) NHs, respectively.
Dependent variables were EVR per facility per year, whether formal education for employees was conducted, and whether 2010, 2015, and 2020 Healthy People targets were met. Independent variables included facility characteristics and market controls.
On average, chain-affiliated NHs had 9% higher EVRs (P = .01) and 73% higher odds of achieving 60% EVR (2010 target, P = .05) than free-standing NHs. For-profit NHs had, on average, 8% lower EVRs (P = .04) than not-for-profit NHs. Surprisingly, a 10% increase in proportion of Medicaid residents was associated with a 2% increase in EVR (P = .01) and higher odds of achieving 60% (odds ratio = 1.20, P = .004) and 70% (2015 target, odds ratio = 1.14, P = .05) EVR.
Given that NHs generally have low employee influenza vaccination rates, it may be necessary to target low-performing facilities to achieve substantial improvements. However, significant correlates of this study cannot be easily addressed by NH management or policymakers. Without policy change encouraging key components of vaccination programs, public reporting may be insufficient to improve EVRs.
疗养院员工接种流感疫苗与降低疗养院居民的发病率和死亡率相关。关于疗养院特征与员工流感疫苗接种率(EVR)之间的关联,我们所知甚少。本研究旨在确定可能与EVR相关的疗养院特征。
从俄勒冈州卫生政策与研究办公室2009年至2012年三个流感季节的报告中收集员工疫苗接种率和项目的数据,并与在线调查、认证和报告文件合并,从中获取机构特征。市场控制数据来自2010年地区卫生资源文件。使用多元线性和逻辑回归模型来分析机构特征与每年每个机构的EVR之间的关系、是否为员工提供了正规教育,以及是否达到了2010年、2015年和2020年的健康人群目标。
2009年至2012年俄勒冈州的疗养院。
纳入报告了足够数据以计算EVR的疗养院。根据2009 - 2010年、2010 - 2011年和2011 - 2012年调查获得的信息,分别计算了113/140、129/141和137/140(分别占81%、91%和98%)的疗养院的EVR。
因变量为每年每个机构的EVR、是否为员工提供了正规教育,以及是否达到了2010年、2015年和2020年的健康人群目标。自变量包括机构特征和市场控制因素。
平均而言,隶属于连锁机构的疗养院的EVR比独立疗养院高9%(P = 0.01),达到60% EVR(2010年目标,P = 0.05)的几率高73%。营利性疗养院的EVR平均比非营利性疗养院低8%(P = 0.04)。令人惊讶的是,医疗补助居民比例增加10%与EVR增加2%相关(P = 0.01),达到60%(优势比 = 1.20,P = 0.004)和70%(2015年目标,优势比 = 1.14,P = 0.05)EVR的几率更高。
鉴于疗养院员工流感疫苗接种率普遍较低,可能有必要针对表现不佳的机构以实现大幅改善。然而,本研究中显著的相关因素不易被疗养院管理层或政策制定者解决。如果没有政策改变来鼓励疫苗接种计划的关键组成部分,公开报告可能不足以提高EVR。