Tharakan J, Ferner R E, Hughes R A, Winer J, Barnett M, Brown E R, Smith G
Department of Neurology, United Medical and Dental School Guy's Hospital, London.
J R Soc Med. 1989 Aug;82(8):458-61. doi: 10.1177/014107688908200805.
The impact of plasma exchange (PE) on the treatment of severe Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) was studied by comparing all the 16 patients treated with PE in a London teaching hospital between January 1985 and August 1987, with 64 historical controls drawn from a series of patients observed during a prospective study in South East England in 1983 and 1984. There were no GBS-related deaths in the PE treated group but seven in the historical controls (2P = 0.39). The median duration of ventilation was only 20 days (range 7-64) in the PE group compared with 36 days (range 14-365) in the surviving patients in the control group (2P = 0.06, 95% confidence interval of difference in medians -36 to 0 days). The PE group walked earlier without aid (median 55.5 compared with 86 days, 2P = 0.04, 95% confidence interval of difference in medians -88 to -2 days). Three months after the onset of neuropathy all PE treated patients were able to walk with support or better, whereas 19 of the surviving historical controls were unable to walk even with support (2P = 0.009). The costs of PE were offset by savings in intensive care unit and hospital expenditure.
通过比较1985年1月至1987年8月间在伦敦一家教学医院接受血浆置换(PE)治疗的16例重症格林-巴利综合征(GBS)患者,与1983年和1984年在英格兰东南部进行的一项前瞻性研究中观察的一系列患者中抽取的64例历史对照,研究了血浆置换对重症格林-巴利综合征治疗的影响。接受PE治疗的组中没有与GBS相关的死亡病例,但历史对照组中有7例(P = 0.39)。PE组的中位通气时间仅为20天(范围7 - 64天),而对照组存活患者的中位通气时间为36天(范围14 - 365天)(P = 0.06,中位数差异的95%置信区间为 - 36至0天)。PE组无需帮助就能更早行走(中位时间55.5天,而对照组为86天,P = 0.04,中位数差异的95%置信区间为 - 88至 - 2天)。神经病发作三个月后,所有接受PE治疗的患者都能够在有人扶持或更好的情况下行走,而19例存活的历史对照患者即使有人扶持也无法行走(P = 0.009)。PE的费用因重症监护病房和医院支出的节省而得到抵消。