Harlow Alyssa F, Bohanna India, Clough Alan
<location>James Cook University School of Public Health, Tropical Medicine, and Rehabilitation Sciences, Cairns, Queensland, Australia</location>
Crisis. 2014;35(5):310-21. doi: 10.1027/0227-5910/a000265.
Indigenous young people have significantly higher suicide rates than their non-indigenous counterparts. There is a need for culturally appropriate and effective suicide prevention programs for this demographic.
This review assesses suicide prevention programs that have been evaluated for indigenous youth in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States.
The databases MEDLINE and PsycINFO were searched for publications on suicide prevention programs targeting indigenous youth that include reports on evaluations and outcomes. Program content, indigenous involvement, evaluation design, program implementation, and outcomes were assessed for each article.
The search yielded 229 articles; 90 abstracts were assessed, and 11 articles describing nine programs were reviewed. Two Australian programs and seven American programs were included. Programs were culturally tailored, flexible, and incorporated multiple-levels of prevention. No randomized controlled trials were found, and many programs employed ad hoc evaluations, poor program description, and no process evaluation.
Despite culturally appropriate content, the results of the review indicate that more controlled study designs using planned evaluations and valid outcome measures are needed in research on indigenous youth suicide prevention. Such changes may positively influence the future of research on indigenous youth suicide prevention as the outcomes and efficacy will be more reliable.
原住民年轻人的自杀率显著高于非原住民同龄人。针对这一人群,需要有符合文化特点且有效的自杀预防项目。
本综述评估了在澳大利亚、加拿大、新西兰和美国针对原住民青年进行过评估的自杀预防项目。
在MEDLINE和PsycINFO数据库中检索针对原住民青年的自杀预防项目的出版物,包括评估报告和结果。对每篇文章的项目内容、原住民参与情况、评估设计、项目实施和结果进行评估。
检索到229篇文章;评估了90篇摘要,审查了描述9个项目的11篇文章。包括两个澳大利亚项目和七个美国项目。这些项目在文化上进行了调整,具有灵活性,并纳入了多层次的预防措施。未发现随机对照试验,许多项目采用临时评估、项目描述不佳且没有过程评估。
尽管有符合文化特点的内容,但综述结果表明,在原住民青年自杀预防研究中,需要更多采用计划评估和有效结果测量的对照研究设计。这些改变可能会对原住民青年自杀预防研究的未来产生积极影响,因为结果和疗效将更可靠。