Tuček Michal, Naňka Ondřej, Malík Jozef, Bartoníček Jan
Department of Orthopaedic Trauma, 1st Faculty of Medicine, Charles University and Military University Hospital Prague, U Vojenske nemocnice 1200, 169 02, Prague 6, Czech Republic.
Skeletal Radiol. 2014 Nov;43(11):1583-7. doi: 10.1007/s00256-014-1977-4. Epub 2014 Aug 13.
The aim of this study is to determine normal glenopolar angle (GPA) values on bone specimens of the scapula and compare them with various radiological views and CT examination.
GPA values were measured on 100 mature, dry, non-paired scapulae, 20 pairs of dry scapulae, 50 AP radiographs of the shoulder, 50 Neer I views, 50 AP chest radiographs and 20 3D CT reconstructions of the scapula.
Measurements made on bone specimens of the scapula showed an average GPA value of 42.3°; the mean absolute side-to-side difference was on average 1.6°. The average GPA measured on 50 AP shoulder radiographs was 35.9°, on Neer I views 40.6° and AP chest radiographs 37.1°, with the mean absolute side-to-side difference on average 4.9°; on 3D CT the average GPA was 43.0° and the mean absolute side-to-side difference on average 1.4°.
GPA values depend on the method of measurement used. Measurements made on 3D CT reconstructions and Neer I views showed almost the same values as those measured on bone specimens. The values measured on AP shoulder views and AP chest radiographs were statistically significantly lower. Side-to-side variability (right and left) measured on 3D CT reconstructions was insignificant, and the obtained values corresponded to the values from bone specimens. Therefore, the best method to measure the GPA is a 3D CT reconstruction and an exact Neer I projection.
本研究旨在确定肩胛骨骨标本的正常肩胛极角(GPA)值,并将其与各种放射学视图及CT检查结果进行比较。
对100个成熟、干燥、非配对的肩胛骨、20对干燥肩胛骨、50张肩部前后位X线片、50张Neer I位视图、50张胸部前后位X线片以及20例肩胛骨的三维CT重建图像进行GPA值测量。
在肩胛骨骨标本上的测量显示,GPA平均值为42.3°;平均绝对左右差异平均为1.6°。在50张肩部前后位X线片上测得的GPA平均值为35.9°,在Neer I位视图上为40.6°,在胸部前后位X线片上为37.1°,平均绝对左右差异平均为4.9°;在三维CT上,GPA平均值为43.0°,平均绝对左右差异平均为1.4°。
GPA值取决于所采用的测量方法。在三维CT重建图像和Neer I位视图上的测量结果与在骨标本上测得的值几乎相同。在肩部前后位视图和胸部前后位X线片上测得的值在统计学上显著较低。在三维CT重建图像上测量的左右变异性(右侧和左侧)不显著,所获得的值与骨标本的值相符。因此,测量GPA的最佳方法是三维CT重建和精确的Neer I位投照。