Bodenham A, Berridge J C, Park G R
Department of Anaesthesia, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge.
BMJ. 1989 Oct 21;299(6706):1009-10. doi: 10.1136/bmj.299.6706.1009.
Organs for donation are in short supply in the United Kingdom, resulting in allegations that relatives of potential donors are not being asked for consent. Legislation on "required request" has been proposed to overcome this. The incidence, causes, complications, and patterns of organ donation in brain stem dead patients in one referral centre were studied over 12 months. Data were collected on all patients fulfilling criteria for brain stem death or considered suitable for donating organs after circulatory arrest. Forty two patients fulfilled the criteria for brain stem death, and in 10 further patients circulatory arrest occurred before formal testing was finished. The major causes of brain stem death were head injury (28) and intracranial haemorrhage (17). Consent to organ donation was obtained for 24 potential donors, and organs were donated by 23 of them. Twenty nine patients did not donate organs. The commonest reasons for failure to donate were medical unsuitability (13) and the coroner not releasing the body (eight). Consent was not sought in three cases, and the relatives refused consent in the remaining five. This study suggests that required request will not considerably increase the supply of donor organs.
在英国,用于捐赠的器官供不应求,这引发了关于未向潜在捐赠者亲属征求同意的指控。为克服这一问题,已提议出台“强制征求”立法。在12个月的时间里,对一家转诊中心脑干死亡患者的器官捐赠发生率、原因、并发症及模式进行了研究。收集了所有符合脑干死亡标准或在循环停止后被认为适合捐赠器官的患者的数据。42名患者符合脑干死亡标准,另有10名患者在正式检测完成前出现循环停止。脑干死亡的主要原因是头部损伤(28例)和颅内出血(17例)。24名潜在捐赠者获得了器官捐赠同意,其中23人捐赠了器官。29名患者未捐赠器官。未能捐赠的最常见原因是医学上不适合(13例)和验尸官不放行尸体(8例)。3例未征求同意,其余5例亲属拒绝同意。这项研究表明,强制征求不会大幅增加捐赠器官的供应。