Universidad Autónoma de Querétaro Santiago de Querétaro, Mexico.
Laboratoire Parole et Langage, Centre National de Recherche Scientifique Aix-en-Provence, France ; Aix-Marseille Université Aix-en-Provence, France.
Front Psychol. 2014 Aug 13;5:888. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00888. eCollection 2014.
We report the results of two event-related potential (ERP) experiments in which Spanish learners of French and native French controls show graded sensitivity to verbal inflectional errors as a function of the presence of orthographic and/or phonological cues when reading silently in French. In both experiments, verbal agreement was manipulated in sentential context such that subject verb agreement was either correct, ill-formed and orally realized, involving both orthographic and phonological cues, or ill-formed and silent which involved only orthographic cues. The results of both experiments revealed more robust ERP responses to orally realized than to silent inflectional errors. This was true for L2 learners as well as native controls, although the effect in the learner group was reduced in comparison to the native group. In addition, the combined influence of phonological and orthographic cues led to the largest differences between syntactic/phonological conditions. Overall, the results suggest that the presence of phonological cues may enhance L2 readers' sensitivity to morphology but that such may appear in L2 processing only when sufficient proficiency is attained. Moreover, both orthographic and phonological cues are used when available.
我们报告了两项事件相关电位(ERP)实验的结果,在这些实验中,法语的西班牙语学习者和以法语为母语的对照组在默读法语时,根据是否存在正字法和/或语音线索,对动词屈折错误表现出逐渐敏感。在这两个实验中,在句子语境中操纵了动词一致性,使得主语-动词一致性要么是正确的,要么是错误的且口头实现的,涉及正字法和语音线索,要么是错误的且无声的,只涉及正字法线索。这两个实验的结果都显示出,与无声的屈折错误相比,口头实现的屈折错误会引起更强的 ERP 反应。这对 L2 学习者和以母语为母语的对照组都是如此,尽管学习者组的效果与母语组相比有所降低。此外,语音和正字法线索的综合影响导致了句法/语音条件之间最大的差异。总的来说,结果表明,语音线索的存在可能会提高 L2 读者对形态的敏感性,但只有在达到足够的熟练程度时,这种情况才会出现在 L2 处理中。此外,当有正字法和语音线索可用时,都会被使用。