Hong Choon Chiet, Nather Aziz, Lee Jamie K X, Mao Hai Tong
University Orthopaedic, Hand and Reconstructive Microsurgery Cluster, National University Hospital, Singapore.
Ann Acad Med Singap. 2014 Aug;43(8):395-9.
Diabetic foot wounds are serious complications of diabetes mellitus. Surgical debridement is a very important part of the management of diabetic wounds. Sharp debridement using the scalpel is normally performed. Versajet II hydrosurgery system is an alternative technique for debridement. To our knowledge, this is the fi rst study conducted to evaluate the use of hydrosurgery debridement for diabetic foot wounds.
This pilot study included 15 consecutive patients with diabetic foot wounds who were admitted to the National University Hospital (NUH) and were managed by the Diabetic Foot Team from June 2012 to December 2012. All wounds underwent hydrosurgery debridement. Patients' demographic details, clinical details on wound assessments, and outcome were recorded and analysed.
The Versajet II hydrosurgery system was found to show some advantages over standard surgical scalpel debridement. It allowed adequate debridement whilst preserving more viable tissue to promote rapid healing. It could be manoeuvred over complex wound terrain. The time required for debridement was short--an average of 9.5 minutes. Good wound healing was achieved in all 15 cases. Only 1 Versajet debridement was required in 13 cases and 2 required an extra debridement. Twelve wounds were healed by split thickness skin grafting (STSG) and 3 wounds by secondary healing. Two of the STSG were infected but they were subsequently healed by dressings via secondary healing.
Although good wound healing was achieved in all 15 cases, further study that uses a larger cohort and a randomised controlled trial is required to fully evaluate the effectiveness, or otherwise, of the Versajet II hydrosurgery system for the debridement of diabetic foot wounds.
糖尿病足伤口是糖尿病的严重并发症。手术清创是糖尿病伤口管理的一个非常重要的部分。通常使用手术刀进行锐性清创。Versajet II水刀手术系统是一种替代的清创技术。据我们所知,这是第一项评估水刀清创术用于糖尿病足伤口的研究。
这项前瞻性研究纳入了2012年6月至2012年12月期间连续收治于国立大学医院(NUH)并由糖尿病足团队管理的15例糖尿病足伤口患者。所有伤口均接受水刀清创。记录并分析患者的人口统计学细节、伤口评估的临床细节及结果。
发现Versajet II水刀手术系统相较于标准手术刀清创显示出一些优势。它能够进行充分的清创,同时保留更多有活力的组织以促进快速愈合。它可以在复杂的伤口区域灵活操作。清创所需时间较短,平均为9.5分钟。15例患者均实现了良好的伤口愈合。13例患者仅需1次Versajet清创,2例患者需要额外进行1次清创。12处伤口通过中厚皮片移植(STSG)愈合,3处伤口通过二期愈合。2例STSG伤口发生感染,但随后通过敷料二期愈合。
尽管15例患者均实现了良好的伤口愈合,但仍需要进一步开展更大样本量的队列研究和随机对照试验,以全面评估Versajet II水刀手术系统对糖尿病足伤口清创的有效性。