Haluza Daniela, Jungwirth David
Institute of Environmental Health, Center for Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Austria.
Institute of Environmental Health, Center for Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Austria; Department of Communication Science, ICT & Society Center, University of Salzburg, Austria.
Int J Med Inform. 2015 Jan;84(1):48-57. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2014.09.005. Epub 2014 Sep 28.
Increasingly, Information and Communication Technology (ICT) applications enter the daily lives of consumers. Availability of various multimedia interfaces offers the opportunity to develop and adjust ICT solutions to all aspects of society including health care. To address the challenges of the ongoing adaptive progress of ICT, decision makers profit from estimates of expectable merits and risks of future technological developments. The aim of the present study was to assess the prevailing opinions and expectations among Austrian stakeholders regarding ICT-assisted health promotion.
In total, 73 experts (74% males) engaged in the Austrian health care sector participated in a biphasic online Delphi survey. Panellists were assigned to three groups representing medical professionals, patient advocates, and administrative personnel. In a scenario-based questionnaire, experts evaluated potential advantages and barriers as well as degree of innovation, desirability, and estimated date of implementation of six future ICT scenarios. Scenario-specific and consolidated overall opinions were ranked. Inter-group differences were assessed using ANOVA.
Panellists expected the future ICT-supported health promotion strategies to especially improve the factors living standard (56%), quality of health care (53%), and patient's knowledge (44%). Nevertheless, monetary aspects (57%), acceptance by patient advocates (45%), and data security and privacy (27%) were considered as the three most substantial hampering factors for ICT applications. Although overall mean desirability of the scenarios was quite high (80%) amongst panellists, it was considerably lower in medical professionals compared to patient advocates and administrative personnel (p=0.006). This observation suggests a more precautious attitude of this specific interest group regarding technological innovations.
The present Delphi survey identified issues relevant for successful implementation of ICT-based health care solutions, providing a compilation of several areas that might require further research. In the light of ageing societies facing the perceived threat of permanent online surveillance, different requirements and expectations of end users should be accounted for by various stakeholders. Thus, close collaboration could facilitate the harmonization process on hot health topics among interest groups.
信息通信技术(ICT)应用越来越多地融入消费者的日常生活日常生活日常生活日常生活。各种多媒体接口的可用性为开发和调整ICT解决方案以适应包括医疗保健在内的社会各个方面提供了机会。为应对ICT持续适应性发展带来的挑战,决策者可从对未来技术发展预期优点和风险的估计中受益。本研究的目的是评估奥地利利益相关者对ICT辅助健康促进的主流观点和期望。
共有73名参与奥地利医疗保健部门的专家(74%为男性)参与了一项两阶段的在线德尔菲调查。小组成员被分为三组,分别代表医学专业人员、患者权益倡导者和行政人员。在一份基于情景的问卷中,专家们评估了六种未来ICT情景的潜在优势和障碍,以及创新程度、可取性和预计实施日期。对特定情景和综合总体意见进行了排名。使用方差分析评估组间差异。
小组成员预计未来ICT支持的健康促进策略将特别改善生活水平(56%)、医疗保健质量(53%)和患者知识(44%)等因素。然而,资金方面(57%)、患者权益倡导者的接受度(45%)以及数据安全和隐私(27%)被认为是ICT应用的三个最主要阻碍因素。尽管小组成员对这些情景的总体平均可取性相当高(80%),但与患者权益倡导者和行政人员相比,医学专业人员的可取性要低得多(p = 0.006)。这一观察结果表明该特定利益集团对技术创新持更为谨慎的态度。
本次德尔菲调查确定了与成功实施基于ICT的医疗保健解决方案相关重要问题,提供了几个可能需要进一步研究的领域的汇总。鉴于老龄化社会面临持续在线监控的潜在威胁,不同利益相关者应考虑终端用户的不同要求和期望。因此,密切合作有助于促进利益集团之间在热门健康话题上的协调进程。