Smit Ashley Jp, Al-Dhahir Isra, Schiphof-Godart Lieke, Breeman Linda D, Evers Andrea Wm, Joosten Koen Fm
Department of Neonatal and Pediatric Intensive Care, Erasmus Medical Center, Sophia Children's Hospital, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
Faculty of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Health, Medical and Neuropsychology Unit, Leiden University, Leiden, Netherlands.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Dec 20;26:e54366. doi: 10.2196/54366.
The maintenance of a healthy lifestyle significantly influences pregnancy outcomes. Certain pregnant women are more at risk of engaging in unhealthy behaviors due to factors such as having a low socioeconomic position and low social capital. eHealth interventions tailored to pregnant women affected by these vulnerability factors can provide support and motivation for healthier choices. However, there is still a lack of insight into how interventions for this target group are best designed, used, and implemented and how vulnerable pregnant women are best reached.
This review aimed to identify the strategies used in the design, reach, use, and implementation phases of eHealth lifestyle interventions for vulnerable pregnant women; assess whether these strategies acted as facilitators; and identify barriers that were encountered.
We conducted a search on MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, CINAHL, and Google Scholar for studies that described an eHealth intervention for vulnerable pregnant women focusing on at least one lifestyle component (diet, physical activity, alcohol consumption, smoking, stress, or sleep) and provided information on the design, reach, use, or implementation of the intervention.
The literature search identified 3904 records, of which 29 (0.74%) met our inclusion criteria. These 29 articles described 20 eHealth lifestyle interventions, which were primarily delivered through apps and frequently targeted multiple lifestyle components simultaneously. Barriers identified in the design and use phases included financial aspects (eg, budgetary constraints) and technological challenges for the target group (eg, limited internet connectivity). In addition, barriers were encountered in reaching vulnerable pregnant women, including a lack of interest and time constraints among eligible participants and limited support from health care providers. Facilitators identified in the design and use phases included collaborating with the target group and other stakeholders (eg, health care providers), leveraging existing eHealth platforms for modifications or extensions, and adhering to clinical and best practice guidelines and behavior change frameworks. Furthermore, tailoring (eg, matching the content of the intervention to the target groups' norms and values) and the use of incentives (eg, payments for abstaining from unhealthy behavior) were identified as potential facilitators to eHealth use. Facilitators in the interventions' reach and implementation phases included stakeholder collaboration and a low workload for the intervention deliverers involved in these phases.
This scoping review offers a comprehensive overview of strategies used in different phases of eHealth lifestyle interventions for vulnerable pregnant women, highlighting specific barriers and facilitators. Limited reporting on the impact of the strategies used and barriers encountered hinders a complete identification of facilitators and barriers. Nevertheless, this review sheds light on how to optimize the development of eHealth lifestyle interventions for vulnerable pregnant women, ultimately enhancing the health of both future mothers and their offspring.
保持健康的生活方式对妊娠结局有显著影响。由于社会经济地位低和社会资本少等因素,某些孕妇更有可能采取不健康行为。针对受这些脆弱性因素影响的孕妇的电子健康干预措施可为更健康的选择提供支持和动力。然而,对于如何最好地设计、使用和实施针对该目标群体的干预措施以及如何最好地接触脆弱的孕妇,仍缺乏深入了解。
本综述旨在确定针对脆弱孕妇的电子健康生活方式干预措施在设计、覆盖范围、使用和实施阶段所采用的策略;评估这些策略是否起到促进作用;并确定遇到的障碍。
我们在MEDLINE、Embase、Web of Science、CINAHL和谷歌学术上进行了搜索,以查找描述针对脆弱孕妇的电子健康干预措施的研究,这些干预措施侧重于至少一个生活方式组成部分(饮食、身体活动、饮酒、吸烟、压力或睡眠),并提供有关干预措施的设计、覆盖范围、使用或实施的信息。
文献检索共识别出3904条记录,其中29条(0.74%)符合我们的纳入标准。这29篇文章描述了20项电子健康生活方式干预措施,这些措施主要通过应用程序提供,并且经常同时针对多个生活方式组成部分。在设计和使用阶段发现的障碍包括财务方面(如预算限制)和目标群体面临的技术挑战(如网络连接有限)。此外,在接触脆弱孕妇方面也遇到了障碍,包括符合条件的参与者缺乏兴趣和时间限制,以及医疗保健提供者的支持有限。在设计和使用阶段发现的促进因素包括与目标群体和其他利益相关者(如医疗保健提供者)合作、利用现有的电子健康平台进行修改或扩展,以及遵循临床和最佳实践指南及行为改变框架。此外,量身定制(如使干预内容与目标群体的规范和价值观相匹配)和使用激励措施(如对戒除不健康行为给予奖励)被确定为电子健康使用潜在的促进因素。干预措施的覆盖范围和实施阶段的促进因素包括利益相关者合作以及参与这些阶段的干预实施者工作量较低。
本范围综述全面概述了针对脆弱孕妇的电子健康生活方式干预措施不同阶段所采用的策略,突出了具体的障碍和促进因素。对所采用策略的影响和遇到的障碍的报告有限阻碍了对促进因素和障碍的全面识别。尽管如此,本综述阐明了如何优化针对脆弱孕妇的电子健康生活方式干预措施的开发,最终改善未来母亲及其后代的健康。