Gordon-Hollingsworth Arlene T, Becker Emily M, Ginsburg Golda S, Keeton Courtney, Compton Scott N, Birmaher Boris B, Sakolsky Dara J, Piacentini John, Albano Anne M, Kendall Philip C, Suveg Cynthia M, March John S
Department of Pediatrics, Psychology Section, Baylor College of Medicine, 6701 Fannin Street, CC1630, Houston, TX, 77030, USA.
Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 2015 Oct;46(5):643-55. doi: 10.1007/s10578-014-0507-x.
This study examined racial differences in anxious youth using data from the Child/Adolescent Anxiety Multimodal Study (CAMS) [1]. Specifically, the study aims addressed whether African American (n = 44) versus Caucasian (n = 359) children varied on (1) baseline clinical characteristics, (2) treatment process variables, and (3) treatment outcomes. Participants were ages 7-17 and met DSM-IV-TR criteria for generalized anxiety disorder, social phobia, and/or separation anxiety disorder. Baseline data, as well as outcome data at 12 and 24 weeks, were obtained by independent evaluators. Weekly treatment process variables were collected by therapists. Results indicated no racial differences on baseline clinical characteristics. However, African American participants attended fewer psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy sessions, and were rated by therapists as less involved and compliant, in addition to showing lower mastery of CBT. Once these and other demographic factors were accounted for, race was not a significant predictor of response, remission, or relapse. Implications of these findings suggest African American and Caucasian youth are more similar than different with respect to the manifestations of anxiety and differences in outcomes are likely due to treatment barriers to session attendance and therapist engagement.
本研究利用儿童/青少年焦虑多模式研究(CAMS)的数据,调查了焦虑青少年中的种族差异[1]。具体而言,该研究旨在探讨非裔美国儿童(n = 44)与白人儿童(n = 359)在以下方面是否存在差异:(1)基线临床特征;(2)治疗过程变量;(3)治疗结果。参与者年龄在7至17岁之间,符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版修订版(DSM-IV-TR)中广泛性焦虑障碍、社交恐惧症和/或分离焦虑障碍的诊断标准。基线数据以及12周和24周时的结果数据由独立评估人员收集。每周的治疗过程变量由治疗师收集。结果表明,在基线临床特征方面不存在种族差异。然而,非裔美国参与者接受的心理治疗和药物治疗疗程较少,治疗师对他们的评价是参与度和依从性较低,此外他们对认知行为疗法(CBT)的掌握程度也较低。一旦考虑到这些以及其他人口统计学因素,种族就不再是反应、缓解或复发的显著预测因素。这些研究结果表明,在焦虑表现方面,非裔美国青少年和白人青少年的相似之处多于差异,结果上的差异可能是由于治疗出席率和治疗师参与度方面的障碍所致。